The operator should not have had been flying their craft on another's property.
The operator should not have had been flying their craft on another's property.
Edit: OK This is getting downvoted, so I'll clarify. I'm not saying I like the fact that this is how the law in the USA is, but that's how it is. It is legally considered an aircraft. He shot down an aircraft.
Does it need to change? Yes. Is it changed now? No.
Edit 2: links for people interested. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unmanned_aerial_vehicle > is an aircraft without a human pilot aboard https://www.faa.gov/uas/model_aircraft/ https://www.faa.gov/uas/publications/model_aircraft_operator...
[1] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/05/30/317074394/drone...
There's also limitations to how tall you can build structures, even on your own property, so erecting a giant tower to claim more airspace isn't a solution!
Bonus Trivia: Few homeowners own the ground beneath their home unless they have something called "Mineral Rights".
http://www.propertycasualty360.com/2014/12/02/are-drones-alw...
You don't have to be above 400ft to be an aircraft. You have to be above 400ft for the FAA to give a shit about regulating what you do. If you shot down an airplane landing on your field you'd be in trouble.
I don't agree with it but that's how it is.
No, it is an aircraft in any case. It may be an improperly-operated aircraft, which would open the operator up to sanction, but I'm pretty sure that you aren't allowed to shoot down improperly-operated aircraft over your property, including in the altitude range in which the airspace is within the scope of your legal property rights.
The tl;dr of that - it is a bad idea to trespass in Texas as the threshold for a property owner being able to justify a shoot first and ask questions later policy is pretty low.
In all my years living here, I can't recall a single incident in the news where a property owner who used deadly force against a trepasser was actually indicted by a grand jury. I'm obviously not trying to imply that it couldn't possibly happen though.
http://www.faa.gov/news/updates/?newsid=76381
"Myth #3: The FAA doesn't control airspace below 400 feet
Fact—The FAA is responsible for air safety from the ground up. Under 49 U.S.C. § 40103(b)(2), the FAA has broad authority to prescribe regulations to protect individuals and property on the ground and to prevent collisions between aircraft, between aircraft and land or water vehicles, and between aircraft and airborne objects. Consistent with its authority, the FAA presently has regulations that apply to the operation of all aircraft, whether manned or unmanned, and irrespective of the altitude at which the aircraft is operating. For example, 14 C.F.R. § 91.13 prohibits any person from operating an aircraft in a careless or reckless manner so as to endanger the life or property of another."
I would say in this case, it's reasonable to assume a hovering drone with a camera, pointed at your house is reckless enough to warrant suspicion from the homeowner, and allow him to act accordingly.
The operator of the drone was definitely operating outside of the regulations in place, but that doesn't make it any less an aircraft. He should have been within line of sight of his craft. If he wasn't then the operator was breaking regulations.
https://www.faa.gov/uas/model_aircraft/ >Don't be careless or reckless with your unmanned aircraft – you could be fined for endangering people or other aircraft
So the operator could get fined, but does that give the home owner the right to shoot down an aircraft? We'll see as this issue plays out in court.
If you want to get absurd then give me a piece of paper and a minute and I can make you an "aircraft" that has a value of $0.05 or less. Just because it's flying through the air it's not necessarily an "aircraft".
Here's another "aircraft" according to your definition: http://www.instructables.com/id/Rubberband-Helicopters-step-...
The point is that there are certain classes of aircraft with varying degrees of certification for airworthiness and if it doesn't fall into any of those classes I'm not sure that I agree that it's an "aircraft" at least in the legal sense.
If you really want to argue that anything which is in the air and not touching the ground is an aircraft then I am an aircraft. Every time I jump off the ground.
So are all these crazy mountain bikers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IsiEUx6Zwrg
I mean, sure they're on a ballistic trajectory but they're still up in the air in an unsupported fashion. Motocross riders now need pilot's licenses.
I'm all for a good reductionist argument, probably moreso than the average "reasonable" person. But the mental and linguistic gymnastics you're doing to make an RC toy an aircraft are reaching, and not just a little bit.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft
Drones, also have the requirement to be autonomously controlled (UAV), none of your examples meet both requirements. Most don't meet the first, otherwise shooting skeet would be illegal, because they generate more lift then most your other examples.
OK so in that case the paper airplane is an aircraft provided that you fold it to have an airfoil. Done. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Dof_Ks-f9U
Also, if it needs to have a power source, the rubber band helicopter or the rubber band airplane is super legit. That's a power source.
My point isn't that I really think that these are aircraft. It's that trying to apply the rules for "mechanical devices which carry people in them" to things which don't carry people is pretty silly.
This impacts the legality of shooting at the aircraft. To what degree this impacts will be up to the courts and the attorneys.
Of course, the shooter was an idiot for shooting at something in the sky, where the bullets would remain stable and lethal for potentially miles. He should absolutely be punished for that, but not necessarily for destroying the UAV operating illegally aside his house.
1) Model Aircraft (your first FAA link) are not "Aircraft" in the sense of operating under the rules and regulations of private aircraft or commercial aircraft.
2) Within the definitions of personal property, the owner has rights about what they can and cannot do to other property that intrudes on that space.
So in the 2nd case, if a "toy" (aka Model Aircraft) was on their property intentionally (which is to say the owner put it there), there is a bunch of case law that says that can impound it or do what ever they want with it. From errant baseballs breaking windows to toy airplanes (or rockets) which land on their land. Further the owner is liable for any damage it does. So in that regard the landowner was well within their rights to "shoot"[1] a toy airplane out of the sky above their house if they felt threatened. The means employed, a shotgun, only has an effective range of about 250' so by definition the flying vehicle was within the 400' exclusion zone. It doesn't matter if it was a $1500 quad-copter drone or a $1.50 balsa wood wind up airplane.
But then there is the whole question of police usage and surveillance. So for a police unit to be lawfully surveilling you under the 400' limit they need a warrant (currently). Its possible it extends farther than that given opinions like this one [1]. And as the article points out, if you can't tell its the police you can't really be expected to know you aren't within your rights in disabling it.
[1] "Held: Where, as here, the Government uses a device that is not in general public use, to explore details of a private home that would previously have been unknowable without physical intrusion, the surveillance is a Fourth Amendment "search," and is presumptively unreasonable without a warrant. Pp. 3-13." - http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-supreme-court/533/27.html
Flying things under human control are unusual. They are not acts of nature, they are acts of Human-kind.
At the very least: if you are going to fly, and bother people, expect a bothering response.