The last part of my comment is related to the fact that "index tracking" and all the related "investment strategies" rely on the assumption that, over all, things will only go up, i.e. ROI will always be positive. I questioned that assumption. We cannot guarantee that in 30 years' time (let's say) we will still be able to return 3-5% on our huge piles of pension funds' money, no matter the strategy. What I'm saying is that we should be prepared for a stagnating or even deflationary world, financially and economically speaking
EDIT: But yes, we don't know whether one can assume "The S&P500 will average 10% per year for EVARRRRR!!!1".
I'm serious. If the overall economy is "stagnating or even deflationary" for any significant period of time, all of the wheels are going to come off.
(Really want a dark thought? You realize that we've dug up and used all of the easily-available oil, right? When Some Later Generation Gets Its Act Together, they aren't going to have a convenient, cheap source of energy.)
And as for cheap energy - there are plenty more, better sources than oil.
How would you read a DVD without a player? Can you rebuild the player, without specs? Can you rebuild the filesystem, or the decoding?
There is plenty of cheap energy that isn't oil--unfortunately, the exploitation of it without oil reserves to bootstrap with may prove impossible. That's the point being made here.
But yes that's not a disaster-friendly method.
Well, also, the printing press was invented a long time ago, so we actually have loads and loads of dead-tree copies of the really important stuff.
Scenario: you're living in a medieval village. Project: build a thorium reactor. Step one: ???
What an index fund does guarantee is that holders of the fund will do better than the average of the "active" investors, who try to pick and choose the best stocks in the index (which for a broad index is basically "the market"). This is because the active investors, as a whole, receive the "market return", but they do so only after investing resources in researching the companies (which index funds don't do) and because the active investors trade a lot, relative to the index fund, so the active investors incur much greater transaction costs. An index gets the market return, but without incurring the costs active investors do, so the index is certain to have a better net return than the average of all active investors. This doesn't mean that index funds are "a wonderful thing that can never go wrong". It's certainly possible for the market to tank, in which case it's little solace for index fund holders that they beat the performance of the average active investor.
Plenty of nuclear fuel still around, on earth (uranium, thorium, hydrogen) and in the sun (solar power, wind, etc).