Google says ad blockers will save online ads
theregister.co.uk
theregister.co.uk
The fact is that Google, a multi billion dollar company which make ~90% of its revenue through ads, not only allows ad blocking extensions to be installed in its browser (which is rapidly gaining market share) but also not-so-evil enough not to tinker with the Top 10 extension list and allow an ad blocking extension to be listed as the second most downloaded extension. (2 of the top 10 extensions are ad blockers: https://chrome.google.com/extensions/list/popular).
To top it off, they are forthcoming about the ad blockers and how they view it and discussed it openly with everyone, by justifying it as a good thing. They agree with something most of us already know is that the single biggest reason we use ad blocking extensions is because of the intrusive and extremely annoying ads. If ads were non-intrusive and fast and targeted most people wouldn't bother with ad blockers. Google, the biggest online ad company gets it. This is good news.
And this is what the author writes?
"And of course, there's no guarantee that Google will always allow ad blockers."
Is the author really this ignorant? You don't even have to rely on extension to block ads. Hello privoxy: http://www.privoxy.org/
There was a recent story about Google adding a cookie so that people without google accounts/not logged in, got some extra functionality. Instead of being applauded for improving the product, people started moaning that they were harvesting data from everyone. Tracking peoples movements on the web so they can sell that data. I don't know why there's this recent "But what if Google start being evil" meme, but I think I'll trust them until they do show signs of abusing that trust.
This is not meant to flame, I'm really curious why/when the usage shifted.
I waited almost a year before I decided to register an account (this place and other forums) and contribute to the discussion, when I was sure that I can put words together in a sentence that people can understand; only to find out that the best way to write proper English (or any language for that matter) is to write often and make mistakes so that others can point them out and you learn from that.
I would have written those sentences as: "Google has too much Power", "Google has 60 billion dollars"
The usage of have seems wrong to me
I'm asking because, if you push this argument further, you could think that it's good for Google to have all ads served by competitors disappear, to leave only google ads everywhere.
Blocking google text ads with privoxy: http://www.willamowius.de/privoxy.html
The thing with privoxy and most other good ad blocking extensions/software is that you can edit the filter list to block almost everything you could possibly think of. So no matter whatever your argument is Google can not stop you from blocking whatever ads you want to block, regardless of the operating system you use (yes even Google Chrome OS, which is a debain/ubuntu based system. Emphasis on Ubuntu because Canonical/Ubuntu developers actively worked on it prior to the official Chrome OS announcement. Not to mention Chrome OS is opensource and you can rip it apart and do whatever you want to do with it).
Maybe individual advertisers can avoid being annoying and hope that adblockers only target the biggest offenders.
It's a pain though and it's a constant temptation just to turn on easy list and kill everything.
If there was a filter list subscription for those which still permitted 'responsible' ads I'd probably use that instead.
It seems to me that the widespread adoption of adblocking software can only hurt the annoying, short-term thinking advertisers and help the not-annoying, long-term thinking advertisers.
As it gets easier to avoid annoying ads, the PR cost of being annoying will continue to rise until it starts hurting annoying advertisers in the short term - in effect, internalizing the negative externality of their activities.
Right now, online publishers view ad blocking as an annoying evil not worth combatting - under the assumption that <5% of all users block advertisements, that the users that do often aren't advertisers' most desirable demographic, and that playing cat-and-mouse with ad blockers is more annoying than it's worth. But as the percentage of users using ad blockers rises, more online publishers will be open to technical solutions to this problem. I know of multiple projects that incorporate server-to-server ad calls (so the ads are served from the same domain as the content) and slicing of ads into multiple smaller images (so the ads aren't standard IAB image sizes, but chunks of the key content are.) Other projects I've seen tie the presence of advertising to key site functionality, making it impossible to use the site effectively without referencing a visible advertisement. As ad blocking increases to the point where it's material to publishers, blocking ad blocking will spawn a lot of startups.
There's already a good example of this: the increasing use of Local Shared Objects (also known as 'Flash cookies') to store data formerly stored in cookies and even to respawn data in deleted cookies. Use of Local Shared Objects for advertising purposes was extremely rare several years ago. As the proportion of users regularly deleting the cookies that contained unique IDs for ad targeting and frequency capping crept up, the market didn't 'balance' by forgoing unique identifiers in cookies - it found a technical workaround by repurposing rarely-deleted LSOs.
I never really understand it when ad-blocking advocates evangelize to the general public - the more there are, the more likely it is that their blocking will in turn be blocked.
Is there such an option in AdBlock? If there is, I wouldn't mind seeing those ads. Currently they get blocked along with the rest, though.
And anyway many of the block rules target ad networks and platforms. One site may use doubleclick.net's ad servers to serve up great, well-targeted ads and someone else may use the same system to server really obnoxious ads.
Personally, I don't subscribe to any lists and add all the block rules by hand. I really just don't want anything that moves or talks to me. But it ain't easy.
Which site do you want to go to:, the annoying one that forces you to watch an ad, or the one that just has a few less-obtrusive ads that you might block? Which one is going to benefit more from network effects and draw in more users?
That's why I agree with Google's position.
The same thing occurs on the web. I find it very hard to read text if there is something flashing right next to it. For this reason I install NoScript as one of my first add-ons on new systems. It blocks the worst offenders and adds a layer of security to boot.
Simply blocking unauthorized scripts is usually good enough for a while, but eventually I'll get to a few pages with non-flash, non-javascript ads that are so annoying I go out and install AdBlock anyway.
I'm happy to meet in the middle, but I don't intend to waste my time.
Firefox has over 90M active daily users. The Adblock Plus plugin is by far the biggest and most compelling Ad Blocker - it has 11M active daily users right now. Google seems willing to live with this 12% opt-out in effect. I suspect of those 12% of users, most of those wouldn't click ads anyways, so it's not a big deal in the end.
- http://blog.internetnews.com/skerner/2009/05/firefox-hits-27... - https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/statistics/addon/1865
I'm not sure if I trust their motives entirely, but Google's theory about the market balancing itself is right on, IMHO.
"I think there will be a nice equilibrium. If people get too aggressive with ads, then ad blockers will become more popular and companies will get less aggressive with ads. The market will sort itself."
As an Adwords advertiser, I agree. Maybe it's because I am selling a B2B product, but I have no interest in 'aggressive' ads that trick gullible people clicking them (the phrasing from this post last week: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=989729)
P.S. The headline seriously distorts Google's argument. Saying that the market will balance itself out as aggressive ads and ad blockers play off each other is not 'ad blockers will save online ads.' In fact, the Google rep doesn't make that statement at all.
BS. Most people don't install ad blockers because they don't want them. Not everyone is a new age hippy anti consumerism activist.
If an advert annoys you, don't visit that website again. Vote with your feet. That's being honest.
I not lazy, and I won't be installing adblock. I don't think doing so is good for the web.
...BUT not the ones that float in when I've already started reading the page, or that take over my screen when I unwittingly roll over them with the mouse (and obscure their close button), or that feature hot pink silhouettes of people dancing in a .gif loop to sell me car insurance, or use what's apparently some guy's mugshot to tell me about some shady mortgage refinance scheme.
For every informative, polite, and compelling advertisement that represents a meaningful commercial communication, there are about 99 that are equivalent to being shouted at via megaphone.
To me that seems the fairest approach.
They still get the hits, and just think the ads are performing worse, so they better make them even more irritating.
In brief: only 32% of Internet users clicked on at least one ad in a month, and 8% of users accounted for 85% of ad clicks.
The people using ad blocking software are not the people often clicking on these ads, and most of the clicks come from people who click on a lot of ads and are (I'm guessing by this behavior) unlikely to install an ad blocker. In other words, ad blocking is not a threat.
I also have a shellscript to download Youtube videos and feed them to mplayer, since my computer is too slow for most Flash video.