We ran experiments with placing random items from /newest on the front page. It worked poorly. The median story is far too low in quality for this to work—you're basically dumping a bunch of junk on the front page. This doesn't encourage users to tastefully consider the stories, it just provokes annoyance: what is this junk doing on the HN front page? In a best-case scenario, people tune out the bad stories, but that defeats the purpose of having them sift for the good ones, and meanwhile you've partly spoiled the front page.
We didn't roll this out to everybody, but we did enough to conclude that it isn't a good way for HN to solve this problem.