In all seriousness, this is why I don't like the IETF's documents. They write in a verbose way and then don't even provide a reference implementation, in this case, a reference regex that would have done away with lots of dispute and ambiguity. It is my opinion that, in practice, your specification is inherently broken if you can't provide a reference implementation.
(No, BNF doesn't count as reference "implementation". Who uses BNF in their programs to validate strings anyway?)