I guess the disagreements will come down to whether or
not you trust the society to do the right thing. But if
you don't trust the society, why would you want to be
charitable at all?
My country's society != my country's government != humanity as a whole.I believe that giving £5000 worth of anti-malaria nets to people in countries like Malawi and DRC [1] saves more lives than paying £5000 in tax, of which only about £50 would end up in the foreign aid budget [2].
That's not because I think people are evil or society is bad - it's because politicians are part of a system that imposes certain incentives, and they can only do so much. Politicians simply think voters would vote them out of office if they increased foreign aid at the expense of making substantial cuts to health, welfare, education, policing, roads, and so on.
If I've identified what I believe is the most efficient way of doing good, why introduce middlemen when at best they would do the same thing, and at worst they might be ninety-nine percent less efficient?
Ultimately, I think charity is just a device for people
to believe they are better than they really are.
If a person legitimately wanted to become better than they are, how should they go about it if not through generosity of spirit and action?[1] https://www.againstmalaria.com/ [2] http://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2013/mar/20/uk...