This burden is becoming far too great, when this is the cost necessary to achieve innovation.
This burden is becoming far too great, when this is the cost necessary to achieve innovation.
Too many people think the carrot of the temporary monopoly was the point of the patent office.
In other words, we know that the community of ideas gets better with more sharing and building off of other people's ideas. As a society we decided to make laws to encourage this sharing. As a result, technological progress was immense.
Sadly, the current situation seems to strongly suggest that we may need to find better ways to encourage sharing (Open Source has been great for much of software).
Both patents and copyright are failed experiments. They weren't meant to 'benefit creators' or 'guarantee an income', and they cannot take that role in a healthy society.
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150805/15521431864/why-d...
"...the copyright section includes thirteen "shall provide" and just the one measly "shall endeavour." And if you add in the enforcement section you get another thirty eight "shall provide" and just a single "shall endeavour" buried in a footnote unrelated to the key points in the document.
So, for those of you playing along at home, the message being sent by the TPP is pretty damn clear: when it comes to ratcheting up copyright and setting the ground rules for enforcement everything is required and every country must take part. Yet, when it comes to protecting the rights of the public and making sure copyright is more balanced to take into account the public... well, then it's optional."
Copyright has failed in an altogether different manner. The trouble with copyright is what has been erected to enforce it: Laws against circumventing DRM that encourage monopolization of copyright-adjacent markets, absurd statutory damages, internet censorship, easily abused takedown schemes. And the term is far too long.
But if "copyright" is only the ability of an author to sue copyright infringers in court for actual damages, it's basically harmless. If you don't like proprietary software then you can excise it from your life by simply not using it, and actually doing that is continually becoming more practical as free software improves.
The trouble with software patents is that you can't do that. There is no option to build your own system because independent creation is not a defense. And that failure is inherent in the nature of what a patent is. You can't fix it without eliminating software patents entirely.
So nobody really needs to use other people's copyright works. Unlike patented ideas, you can always create your own instead. Or course, sometimes it's expensive and feels like a waste of effort reproducing what's already been done, but it's still not a restriction on doing your own thing the way patents are.
The way I see property ownership is that it's like a store of human labor. When you do work, you might get money from it, you might get a physical object from it (I made a table, now I own that table), or you might get a copyright work from it. All of these things can hold the value of the work you did and can be used to trade for other things. I don't think it's unreasonable to imagine that in a fair world, the people who did that work can keep the stored value they created as long as the market is willing to trade things for it. In the case of computer software, some value is lost whenever somebody uses your work, since you're not able to sell it to them anymore. Value is also lost if the the demand falls (obsolete software) but that's the risk of investing your labor in something with an uncertain lifetime, just as the value of a table is lost if fashions change and people want steel tables instead of wood.
Some copyright work has value and that's why people want to copy it, so they can gain that value for themselves at the expense of the copyright holder. But wouldn't it be more fair to make your own, instead of siphoning value out of other people's work without compensating them?
Of a single part of a software product a company can enjoy trade-secret protection, copyright, and patent protection... then they multiply the force many fold with burdensome one sided 'license agreements'.
This is possible because the bar for disclosure in patents has basically been put at zero. If the patent teaches the invention in question to a single hypothetical omnipotent expert in the art, then it meets the disclosure bar. In many fields patents are obfuscated beyond belief and it is pointless to read them: You'll learn nothing.
Simultaneously, parties keep their source code secret-- but distributed binaries which are obfuscated forms of the source that effectively hide their design, and they use the force of anti-circumvention provisions of copyright law to threaten people who would reverse engineer the software (perhaps to extract some information about the 99.9% of non-patented ideas in it). And yet they enjoy a long lasting copyright protection, the same as other works which are made transparent through their publication.
The patent system on its own is unbalanced, especially for software good which have a much lower resource requirements for their exploration... but when coupled with the other schemes that were hardly envisioned to overlap, the result creates incredible costs, stifles innovation, and is generally bad for society.
http://www.teslamotors.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-yo...
If it's so good for the industry, the patent holders could just choose to make it free. Everyone else could choose to :gasp: pay.
I actually agree with your point. I just want to make it clear what that means. When it comes to patents, to me a compression algorithm is the closest thing in software to a mechanic device. At that level could patent equivalent ideas as hardware. Are we saying no more patents on mechanical inventions or hardware?
For a long time I've thought that the patent office letting crummy patents through as being a separate issue than having patents at all. It also never made sense to separate out software patents from anything else.
I remember very clearly when Ogg Theora was being developed the difficulty they had in choosing a technique that would work and was not already patented. It's not like they were looking up algorithms in a big book and saying "I wonder if that one is patented". They were coming up with techniques independently and then having to search to see if it was patented.
At what point is something obvious to a person skilled in the art? What should be patentable? Should you be able to get a patent across a whole field of techniques because you managed to implement one example of that technique?
The overall approach might be obvious to someone skilled in the art, but the devil is in the details. If someone can patent the overall approach because they have implemented an example of that approach, then it shuts down everybody else. If you have a company that goes around buying up (or making strategic partnerships with companies that own) patents that cover all conceivable approaches, then they can completely lock down any new developments for a couple of decades.
This is the reality of codec development right now. Is this what we want? Is it good for the industry and society in general?
Imagine as a programmer being told, "No matter what idea you have, it is already patented. You are not allowed to program without paying someone a fee. If they decide not to sell to you, then you can't program at all". That's the world of a codec developer. It's something that I personally do not want.
Is it better to patent something and tell the whole world how to do it? Or is it better to just keep it secret? It seems like some refinements to when you can sue might be in order, specifically, I might outlaw suing if you don't market an implementation of your own; that radically changes the value of a lot of property though.
As a programmer, I am firmly against software patents. They are a burden only. How many programmers troll patents thinking, "I'll look for useful techniques so that I can license them in my program"? Even if you wanted to, you couldn't because there are millions of them. And if you start looking, you may get sued for wilful infringement if you forget about something you saw and start using it.
That aside from any arguments about the patentability of ideas rather than inventions. I would be 100% in favour of software patents if the implementation was covered (i.e. the source code). If I used a different implementation for the same idea, then the patent wouldn't hold. Of course such a patent would be useless in a world where software is covered by copyright.
Where did this 'patents are good because they make inventions public' idea suddenly come from?
I've seen it bandied around a lot lately from people who are uncomfortable with directly supporting patents.
No. It's not better. Don't be ridiculous.
> Or is it better to just keep it secret?
How do you imagine anyone will do that?
Imagine I come up with a new compression algorithm that achieves 1:4 compression on 80% of compressed files and normal 1:2 on the rest.
In a patent system I can:
1) Use it privately and not tell anyone. Keeping it secret.
2) Patent it and license it to other people. I risk being sued out of existence by existing patent holders and trolls.
In a non-patent system I can:
1) Use it privately and not tell anyone. Keeping it secret.
2) Share and sell it as a black box implementation. People will immediately reverse engineer the compression method.
???
How is privacy and secrets an issue here?
In both cases (1) is the best choice if you don't want your competitors to get access to your algorithm.
In the patent case its easier for 3rd parties to find the implementation details by doing no work themselves. It's also significantly more risky.
In the non-patent case, people have to actually work to reverse engineer the implementation, sure, but then they're free to use it. There's also no risk in selling and distributing the product.
So, lets see here, things which are better, since both paths lead to the algorithm being made freely available in the end:
1 - Do research, at risk that you'll get sued into oblivion the moment you publish & sell. Even if you don't immediately get sued, you have zero temporary competitive advantage because you just told every competitor what you're doing.
2 - Do research and have temporary competitive advantage once you release it?
The only people who win in the patent way is lawyers.
The 'secrets are bad' argument is a straw man; first you setup the straw man (but then we would never get to know the secret details!!?!!), then you punch it a few times (but sharing knowledge is good! How will the global body of knowledge grow if everything is just secrets??).
It's just daft.
So yes, "It seems like some refinements to when you can sue might be in order"; indeed; ie. never.
It's not about privacy, it's about the competitive advantage of inventing something better.
Why do insanely profitable companies get patents?
That's quite the false dichotomy.
I've always felt that if we allow for software patents (which I'm not sure even that is a good idea), then they should be much more limited (say 5 years) where commercial costs can be recouped, and some profits made as well as being a short enough time that the greater society can still benefit.
Both the scale and scope of what is being approved regarding software patents in this country are ridiculous compared to the natural rate of change and innovation... 20 years ago the average computer would have a lot of trouble trying to display a 1080p video stream. Today just about everyone has something in their pocket that can handle this. We can't limit software expression and bind it for 20 years at a time, for ideas that take a fraction of that time for multiple people to come up with and implement.
The others are laws that a nation creates as a result of specifics surrounding itself. Patents are one such example. These exist solely to spur the sharing of ideas by encouraging inventors to document and share them in detail so that they can later be used by society once the patent expires. A temporary monopoly is granted on an idea to encourage this sharing. This way, ideas aren't lost to eternity simply b/c the inventor didn't have the means to fabricate them. This concept is purely a construct of western nations and culture. It's unlikely an isolated society would arrive at a similar construct naturally.
I am guessing that a lot of us "see what they did there".
We allow for (temporary) ownership of property because it's supposed to encourage benefits to society of various varieties. If it doesn't - and it's starting to become clear that, say, inequality in the US is becoming too high - then we need to change things.
I think it would be a big mistake to admit that yours is the same, because if this doesn't carry you've effectively said you are infringing.
oh that's right. The whole point is they don't want to.
His complaint against H.265 will likely be fixed, and then it too will catch on, just as H.264 did, despite these same types of complaints against it.
Because audio and movie pirates don't care what codecs they use, and VLC has supported pretty much everything you throw at it, patents be damned.
What do you think most early iPod adopters filled the disks with? Surely no legally bought music, lol.
>What do you think most early iPod adopters filled the disks with?
The first iPods shipped with decoders for several patented codecs, including mp3.
This supports my claim that the codecs were not prohibitively expensive to make gadgets that include royalty payments to codec patent holders.
And as often it is with patents, the outcome is more invention. All those workarounds are also innovation.