It is a big place and some will have good experiences some will have bad. Of course, I am glad Tim likes it there. Another person I know really likes it there as well.
But I think overall I have heard more bad than good so far. And I don't think the stories from the original article were made up. Or everyone who blogged/written/shared over beers are all Google PR shils. On the other hand I usually hear more good than bad experiences from Facebook, Google and Microsoft.
Also as another personal story, I interviewed there and had a laughably terrible experience. You'd think -- "Nah, this has got to be a joke" the whole time. ( You can read it here, sorry if you already saw it in yesterday's post https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10065631 )