Warp speed travel is theoretically possible, says astrophysicist
sciencealert.com
sciencealert.com
Either way I seriously recommend some thorough Googling about this subject as that article is unbelievably out of date.
I play Elite: Dangerous once in a while and one thing that game really teaches you is that even 'c' is really slow in astronomical terms. You start to realize that for space colonization to become truly viable we'd have to hope for some real analog of "hyperspace," as "warp" simply won't cut it in the long run.
Good point. Let me rephrase that: a long time from the perspective of the people doing the colonization :)
That's what I'm saying: once you move past the "local neighborhood" things become quite ridiculous.
As far as I understand from popular science, warp drive doesn't actually move the occupants of the vehicle, it moves the space around the ship so in that case there is no time dilation. It takes the same amount of time for people, in and outside, the ship. If your warp drive is limited to 20c then yes it is a problem, but I don't see why would it have to be limited in the first place. Make it go 10^10c and the problem is solved.
That much so much more sense. In addition to the velocity there would also be time spent completely outside of a gravity well. However, the article is really talking about warp.
> Make it go 10^10c and the problem is solved.
Too much energy. From what I understand it's exponential - i.e. more energy would be used getting to Alpha Centauri at 10^10c than at 20c. We don't know exactly how to get to 1c in the first place, but we do know that if we could then e.g. 100c would likely be something that would be out of reach.
Keep in mind that before White optimized the Alcubierre metric, getting to Pluto (AFAIR) with a warp drive would have required the mass of Jupiter. Getting to Alpha Centauri would have required the mass of the observable universe (which is now down to something with "the mass of Voyager 1"). That's the amount of energy we are talking about even at a pitiful 20c.
Right, you would need those rare, stable, dilithium crystals.
The spice must flow.
All of this stuff is a massive longshot, whether or not we can do it it's still interesting.
Even though, as I understand it, General Relativity doesn't forbid FTL explicitly, it doesn't get you out of the causality problems of FTL. At least, I've never seen an explanation of a "warp" style FTL method that doesn't allow for causality violation. I'm all ears, if someone wants to convince me that warp drives can't violate causality.
Here is a practical example: I decide to travel to Alpha Centauri, and I'm there. Time passed for everybody is the same. You cannot cause any problems.
Note that you are not allowed to change reference frames, by doing this. This does sound illogical, since you move to some other location, but if you assume you didn't move, like we did, then it isn't. Actually the space moved, and that might cause some other problems we don't know about.
Iirc, the ftl violates causality thing isn't from going faster than light, but rather because where you end up is outside of the future light cone of where you started.
It's also, I think, outside of your past light cone, so a single ftl trip in a straight line might not have retrocausality, but because the region outside of both the past and future light comes can be considered to be either before or after the start timeplace, by choosing a different reference frame, if you have two ftl trips, that is enough for causing past events.
I think this doesn't matter what happens during the trips, just the start and end timeplaces.
I think we are just not talking about the same "warp" drive. The version that doesn't violate causality works like this. You are not allowed to accelerate( using normal rockets ) to near c velocity and then warp to a stop to some distant location. This would cause problems. Instead you will end up there with all of your accumulated velocity before the warp. Then you have to come to a stop the same way you accelerated.
In other words, warp will change your location but not your velocity in spacetime.
What I'm saying is the "how you get there" doesn't matter.
If you pick a point in spacetime, the future light cone of that point does not depend on your reference frame, and neither does the past light cone.
And, no, I'm fairly sure that the light cone is still a thing even if you do not accelerate.
So, pick a point X in space time, and a point Y which in some inertial frame of reference is "after" that point, but not inside the future light cone of X, such that your ftl device allows point X to influence point Y.
Then there is some other frame of reference where point X is still not inside point Y's past or future light cones, but now is "after" point Y.
Then, the same ftl device would allow point Y to influence point X, or other points in X's past light cone.
(to simplify, assume that the ftl device does not have a maximum "speed" This implies that it can impact any future point. I'm pretty sure that the same line of reasoning with the two points still applies when ftl device is limited to a "speed" of twice c, but I am not well versed in relativity, so I am treating the "speed" of the ftl device as unlimited. I am putting "speed" in quotes to indicate that it isn't a literal speed, so much as a ratio of (I think) distance in some reference frame compared to time in the reference frame, within which the ftl device can reach.)
Note that I have not at any point in this talked about a path between X and Y, or anything like that.
So, you can't get around this by noting that the ftl device never actually goes faster than c in the space it is in, because none of the things deal with the ftl device moving, just influencing things outside of its light cone.
Learn more about relativity( it is really interesting ), otherwise you will always be stuck in your frame of mind.
Take some ftl causation (i.e. two points in spacetime such that one is a causal influence on the other, and such that the spacetime interval between them is spacelike).
Take the one which has a causal influence on the other to be first. Then, by relativity of simultaneity for things which are separated by a spacelike spacetime interval, there is another frame of reference in which the point which is causally influenced by the other point occurs before the point which causally influences the other point.
That is, A influences B, and B is before A.
Which is retrocausality.
Therefore, because any two points in mostly flat spacetime (so like, no black holes or anything) which have spacelike separation can be taken to be before or after eachother, if one has a causal influence on the other, there is a frame of reference in which that would be retrocausality.
edit:
also, do you mean that I don't intuitively understand relativity, or don't intuitively understand light cones?
I don't understand where you are getting the idea that "warp and light cones clearly don't work". Light cones are still used in general relativity (at least locally). Shifting things based on frame of reference still works in general relativity.
Do you have anything to back up your claim that light cones "don't work" with "warp"?
At the very least a good search term?
edit2:
further, consider this quote by alcubierre: ' Miguel Alcubierre briefly discusses some of these issues in a series of lecture slides posted online,[31] where he writes "beware: in relativity, any method to travel faster than light can in principle be used to travel back in time (a time machine)." '
[31] http://ccrg.rit.edu/files/FasterThanLight.pdf
So, you can see, Alcubierre (who, iirc, first showed the negative energy density method of ftl mentioned in the article), also states that it could be used for retrocausality (though there's a caveat based on the “chronology protection conjecture").
So, I think my arguments are fairly well supported.
Your final conclusion is a strawman argument. Those quotes are referring to normal travel through space.