Not just could, would. Choosing your hypothesis after you run the experiment is (or at least should be) a cardinal sin in science for good reason. At the standard p-value cutoff of .05, even when there's absolutely no effect going on the probability of getting a spurious positive result when you do n comparisons is equal to 1 - (.95^n).
So that 5% chance of a type I error if you only look at one test statistic jumps to 40% if you look at ten, and to 72% if you look at 25.
Here's a nice piece of gonzo journalism that deals with this issue: http://io9.com/i-fooled-millions-into-thinking-chocolate-hel...