Hacker News Reader

Comment by conradfr | Hacker News Reader

Not to criticize this project specifically but having done some Angular & React apps I wish these libraries would allow some kind of bridge for JS and jQuery plugins.

Do you need incomplete or lagging Bootstrap port for each new framework of the day ?

Especially when you're not doing a SPA and integrates in an existing website, it leads to duplication.

For example I've used Angular-UI and have encapsulate real Bootstrap components in directives and the advantage of the former was not that obvious because it leads to new and different bugs, incomplete features etc.

View on HN

Have you used React with jQuery plugins? Because you don't really need a bridge

Out of curiosity, what is Bootstrap helping you with?

I'm trying to understand why you'd need bootstrap and jQuery when you're using Angular. I use Angular daily and have never felt the urge to use Bootstrap. In fact an older Angular project had been using bootstrap and I was able to completely eliminate it from the project.

Did angularjs provide a device targeting feature for you? That's all I've used bootstrap for.

Are you saying Angular and Bootstrap provide you the same things? I do not see in what world those two are synonymous, one is basically a glorified ui kit with some limited js backed widgets, the other is a framework for building applications.

No. Not at all.

Let me explain. I see two groups of bootstrap users:

1. Those that use the framework for JavaScript tooling. Things like dropdowns, hamburger menus, tooltips, etc. They typically don't use any of the prepackaged bootstrap styling. This was me for a long time.

2. Those that use the framework for both aesthetic specific CSS and JavaScript.

Angular helps Group 1 rid themselves of bootstrap. Group 2 is largely helpless.

So....asking for a friend. But why is using bootstrap for #2 a bad thing?

It's not necessarily a bad thing. What I meant was that it's much harder to convince someone already relying on prepackaged styling to abandon that for a custom UI.

The full-bootstrap-stack is perfectly fine for things like side projects.

It's not, bootstrap gives you a nice starting point to design your application.

You might have misread. He's wondering if you need Bootstrap when you're using Angular and suggesting that you don't. No where does he conflate the two.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com