No, he's saying that employees using public forums to call other employees (including former employees) "batshit insane" are not welcome within Mozilla.
That's kind of distant from whether the target of that attack is welcome (whether or not they are actually "permanently offended"); its not inconsistent that Mozilla would both come down hard on this type of hateful speech (even where it might be accurate) and not be welcoming to the people for whom the description, or even just the "permanently offended" part, was accurate.
> If I were a current employee at Mozilla, it would be time to shop my resume around to saner workplaces.
Good luck finding a place that tolerates this kind of public attack by employees against other employees (even the kinds of places where the leadership might publicly make such attacks on a disliked outgoing employee are unlikely to tolerate underlings doing so independently -- the privilege of painting a giant PR and legal target on the company like that is generally reserved fairly narrowly, where its tolerated at all.)
If that's really something you need in a workplace, I'm not sure any place that would lose you for that reason would do anything but breathe a sigh of relief for the bullet they dodged down the line by your departure.
Let's do a thought experiment. If the post had been, "[NAME] was one of those batshit insane men's rights types. I'll be glad when all of his kind have left Mozilla and taken their misogyny elsewhere," would the CEO be reacting in the same fashion? Would The Verge write approvingly about it?
If not, then we're really not talking about some studiously neutral principle, and we should stop pretending that we are.
One of those is compatible with the companies code of conduct and the other isn't. So I think it's fair to treat them differently.
According to the article the former clearly is, but I don't imagine Mozilla's HR puts up with misogyny either.
I'm assuming expressing hate towards a group counts as an "exclusionary practice" whereas demanding equal rights isn't.
I say the relevant equivalents are:
Feminists and men's rights types.
Misandrists/misandry and misogynists/misogyny.
I would think is this common sense but HN never disappoints.
No one has suggested that either the CEO or the Verge is acting out of studious neutrality.
Some people have suggested a neutral principal within which the CEO's action is within the range of acceptable actions given the event it responds to, but nothing in your hypothetical -- whether or not one assumes (its not really a thought experiment, its just a projection of one's biases) that the action would have been similar or different -- addresses that.
If, instead of asking if the individual actors behaviors would have been the same, one were to ask would the actions have been justified if they were the same, we would at least be discussing the only neutral principle that has been proposed -- but even then, there is room to debate whether or not there are meaningful differences.
But nice and elaborate strawman that you've set up there.
If I may quote: "No, he's saying that employees using public forums to call other employees (including former employees) "batshit insane" are not welcome within Mozilla."
> But nice and elaborate strawman that you've set up there.
No, a thought experiment. For those who figured they could come up with a neutral principle, I presented another situation to apply those principles to. The general reaction was "well, that's different because of the beliefs of the employee." Which is what I was getting at all along: if you work for Mozilla you either toe the line with Mozilla's ideology or at the very least better keep your opinions to yourself, even anonymously on a dusty corner of an Internet message board. If not, the CEO will denounce you in the media, attempt to find out your identity, and if he succeeds, fire you. Brendan Eich wasn't a one-off; he was a model for the future.
Now it seems a lot of people are fine with that. And that, in turn, is fine! I'm happy for you: you have a major browser which is only for people of your political persuasion, which is not something everyone gets to say. Those who don't care about the ideology of the engineers who write their applications may be less happy, but I suppose that's our problem.
Public attack? Yeah 6 anonymous comments on a website, what an all-out "attack." Oh no, her credibility was tarnished. Oh wait, she did that to herself already by leaving a twitter rant-stream mult-day bridge burning criticizing the company but providing no helpful facts, just rants and complaints. hence the good-riddance