Google finally responds to Europe's antitrust charges
economist.com
economist.com
Interesting. So, Google isn't a monopoly or web search that it provides isn't essential supply. That means, as I understand, there are plenty of comparable rivals in the search area - or the search itself isn't particularly important today.
Is it so? Haven't heard about Europe-based - or anything-based search engines, which were as successful as Google, or even by half as successful. Similarly, I don't know many working people who don't search on the Internet daily. May be they can avoid doing that, but they probably don't want to.
Sounds strange.
Standard Oil held down prices which was good in theory for customers, but it was devastating for competitors and their employees, who spent like any other consumer. Europe's attitude towards Google isn't very free-market minded, but they are asking what kind of society they want, rather than having the economy as the be all and end all of their values.
EDIT: If you're going to downvote without explaining why, then you haven't really helped the conversation, you just made yourself feel less insecure about your own opinion.
Uh, are you saying that Standard Oil should have made business decisions based on what was good for their competitors? This starts to get into collusion.
And I understand that the theory was that Standard Oil would hold prices down, running at a loss in order to kill off all competition, then raise prices as high as it wanted in a non-competitive market. But this doesn't seem to apply to Google's situation as customers can easily move to searching Amazon, eBay, etc. when shopping.
This is exactly what some critics of antitrust law say happens:
> Under the Antitrust laws, a man becomes a criminal from the moment he goes into business, no matter what he does. For instance, if he charges prices which some bureaucrats judge as too high, he can be prosecuted for monopoly or for a successful “intent to monopolize”; if he charges prices lower than those of his competitors, he can be prosecuted for “unfair competition” or “restraint of trade”; and if he charges the same prices as his competitors, he can be prosecuted for “collusion” or “conspiracy.”
Think of it like Wal-Mart: it may provide jobs and cheaper goods to a community, but the wealth is a net outflow towards the Walton family. Local businesses tend to recirculate their profits within the community through investment and higher spending, resulting in a broader standard of life increase.
Europe as a whole is much more concerned with quality of life than America, so it makes sense to see why they would view Google's homogenization of habit as a potential threat.
I think it's worth considering other societies' values when debating their laws compared to your own. There's a lot that America does right that Europeans want no part of, and vice versa. It really depends on who you are as a person.
Providing jobs and cheaper goods to the community sounds like it's putting wealth into the pockets of the community to me. If you can buy a gallon of milk for the kids cheaper at Walmart then you can at the corner store, you have extra money for school supplies, medicine, etc.
>Europe as a whole is much more concerned with quality of life than America
Sorry, I have to roll my eyes at that comment and move on...
2: Go to, say, Ravenna, Italy, and try to get a drink after midnight and on a weekday. You can't. The people there would rather all be on the same schedule (espresso for breakfast, big lunch with the family, work till evening, late dinner, then a stroll around town) instead of having their friendships and families be separated by the graveyard shift. As a hungry American at 2AM it was an inconvenience, but overall it works and people are happy.
If you're still unconvinced, ask a European what they think of paid parental leave, month-long vacations (inb4 productivity argument, Germany offers much longer vacations than America and has higher productivity per worker), national single-payer health care...I could go on. If Americans really, really cared about these things, we would have them by now.
Not to pick on Italy, but:
http://ycharts.com/indicators/italy_youth_unemployment_rate_...
So I wouldn't exactly want to model my economy on Italy.
>If you're still unconvinced, ask a European...
I've spent a lot of time in Europe and had long discussions in the pubs. Great times, nice folks, and I look forward to visiting again. but I still prefer the US.
My family in Gaeta knows the economy has been rough for a while, and yet their (and Italy's) strong social ties have kept society together in ways GDP and unemployment figures can't measure.
Contrast with China, where growth is less than double digits and everybody's losing their mind. GDP doesn't explain why someone on the street dying from a car crash can be ignored by hundreds of people who walk by because they don't want to get involved in something that isn't their problem (punitive laws that potentially transfer liabilities to involved bystanders don't help).
Society is more than economy. People often choose benefits to their society that tax economic growth, like preventing acid rain. If something seems irrevocably inconsistent about someone's decision, then I question the extent to which you choose to think from their perspective.
1. Health care cost 2. Crime (especially violent and gun crime) 3. The lack of a political center ground or any sensible centrist discourse. 4. And of course - broadband and mobile data cost/speed ;-)
(* http://www.nationmaster.com/country-info/compare/United-King... - although I'm sure those statistics are massively affected by area)
If I have an idea for a better highway and money to build it, I still can't just build the highway. If I have a better idea for a search engine, I could wipe out Google.
Google is exposed to market forces, the highway isn't. Your analogy doesn't work at all.
Just because there exists the opportunity for a competitor doesn't mean one will emerge. Until then (if it even happens!) the courts of Europe will continue to view Google as a disproportionately powerful force. Because it's an American company backed and staffed by people who fundamentally see the Internet and global economy in a different light than most Europeans (right to be forgotten, etc), Europeans have every reason to be suspicious.
Not necessarily. There are gigantic network effects propping Facebook up. A Facebook user who wants to try another social network needs to convince all their friends to move. And each of them has to convince their friends.
But to try another search engine takes takes about five seconds. You could switch from Google to Bing immediately and never look back, if you thought Bing were better.
If not, could you name an example of such a company that you would leave alone?
This is a question of place and values. All things considered I think Google's market position is O.K., but if I were a European I would probably think differently. Not everyone wants to live by everyone else's rules (or End User License Agreement). If Europeans believe in antitrust action against Google, even if it is economically disruptive, we should respect that. Just as we should expect them to let us live as we desire elsewhere.
Yeah, well, there's this outfit called Microsoft. They have this service called Bing. You may have heard of it. I'm sure that they'd be pretty offended to be told that they're not "a legitimate competitor".
You can have a legitimate competitor, and still have the majority of people prefer one. That's not the same as a monopoly.
I only said "might", because the question isn't whether Google is more effective per dollar. The question is whether advertising on Bing generates more revenue than it costs. If it does, then businesses would be stupid not to also advertize on Bing.
Also note that this is about product search not search.
People can prefer Google without Google being a monopoly. There's competition, even though Google is ahead. (When multiple companies compete in a market, someone is almost always ahead.)
Google has effective competition. Winning against them does not make Google a monopoly.
In any case, the whole process took about 3 years. Quite a lot in technology terms, but not really that long. 3 years from now, I don't see Google going anywhere nor any competitor taking over -- technology in search hasn't changed much in the last 5 years, if anybody could take a real shot at unseating google they would have done it by now.
Just do a search for "Chicago Hotel" on a desktop browser. Unless you have a gargantuan screen, you will not see a single organic result. You will be given a list of paid ads, and then links to Google's local results. Clicking one of those local results will take you to another screen where you will see more paid ads, a Google Map, and a few seemingly organic results. But if you click on one of these "organic" results, Google then shows you a page where you can book a hotel room - and pay Google a fee for that.
But I don't see how paid ads are an example of using dominance to support their business though; paid ads are just a market that both hotels and resellers bid for space in. In fact, in my results above the google-box results are
- booking.com (ad)
- expedia.com (ad)
- priceline.com (ad)
- hotwire.com (ad)
- trivago.com (ad)
In the past (when Google was touting their "Do no evil" slogan), you would have seen at least as many or more organic results to go along with the paid ads.
By pushing the organic way below the fold, Google is drastically increasing the odds someone will click on their ad. In fact, a lot of these companies are in the organic results but instead of getting their traffic for free, they'll have to pay Google for it.
I'd like to make clear - I have no problem with Google doing things that it deems good for it's bottom line. They have every right to do that, but that is why regulators exist - to make sure that when someone becomes the dominant player, they don't then use that position to eliminate competitors and extort customers.
And while the top 'results' were not 'organic', they were not ads either. They were simply the top rated hotels on google maps near Chicago.
When I clicked on 'More hotel', I was taken to google maps, which showed me top rated hotels as well as ads for hotels.
In terms of giving me the most relevant results, I think this is pretty close.
This is what the actual results are on a 1080p screen.
Was Microsost wrong to use their position as the dominant OS to kill Netscape by effectively banning it from Windows installations? Was Standard Oil wrong to force railroads to not only give them massive discounts but also force the railroads to hurt Standard competitors?
What Google is doing and what Microsoft or Standard Oil did are fantastically profitable tactics that insure their long-term success. The question is, should they be allowed to do that without any restrictions?
But if you're a Google user and you want to switch to some other search engine... you just switch. Instantly.