As with most things in mathematics, the varying perspectives on an object and the relationship between those perspectives are more important than what an object is
per se, to the point where the idea of what an object "is"
per se is often meaningless.
Are the real numbers "actually" Dedekind cuts or equivalence classes of Cauchy sequences? If we prove that both constructions result in isomorphic objects, what difference does it make? Once equivalence has been established, we're free to adopt either perspective as the situation warrants.
Matrices represent linear transformations whether we want them to or not. As someone else pointed out, the operation you've defined is the Hadamard product[1], which is totally valid but doesn't correspond to the composition of linear transformations.
There are other "products", too, like Kronecker product[2] and the Frobenius product[3], each with the own properties, motivations, and relationships to other parts of mathematics. These are neither good nor bad nor anything else — they just are.
I think it was a misstep for the article to be titled What Matrices Are, because the real idea is that when we think of matrices as representing linear functions then the formula for "standard" matrix multiplication corresponds to the composition of linear functions. It's not just some crazy scheme we invented to torture Algebra II students in high school, but a different perspective on the composition operation that has its own advantages and disadvantages relative to other perspectives.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadamard_product_(matrices)
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kronecker_product
[3] http://planetmath.org/frobeniusproduct