But the appeal to IETF standards that brackets that argument, with it's "period, no exceptions" language, is a bit galling. Who cares? The IETF has made all manner of silly rules in its history. Why isn't this simply one of them?
For one thing, the standard was built for an extremely different internet than the one we have today.
(I've used to work at ISP. ICMP echoes towards the customer's machine is a first step in diagnosing what could be wrong - and sometimes it really helps to get an image of what's going on. Sadly, a lot of machines do not respond to those.)
Attempts to reduce surface area that fail to actually achieve their goal and impede the proper functioning of networks the affected system connects to should be avoided whenever possible, no?