What Would Always-On-The-Record Government Look Like?
radar.oreilly.com
radar.oreilly.com
Avoiding blame is the primary reason law codes are so complex and hard to read. The average spending increase is passed to great fanfare and acclaim. The average tax increase is mentioned briefly in an amendment to an amendment to a sub-section of a codicil to a rider on resolution to honor the US Winter Olympics team for their fine performance in... wherever.
Ultimately, this works because of attention shortage. There are people (with various political agendas) who read the text of every bill, cross-reference things, and try to connect the dots. They probably issue press releases every day. They only get the public's attention a few times a year, usually when they discover flagrant abuse of an elected office, a sex scandal, or similar.
In other words, we could already have this, but we don't. Knowing something is very important -- that you should want it -- is completely different from actually wanting it.
I appreciate that news outlets filter through the noise, but sometimes very interesting information gets reported in a dull manner, causing few people to pick it up or get excited about it and share it, or very banal information (say a sex scandal) gets sensationalist reporting, causing it to drown out other important points.
Yes!
> Avoiding blame is the primary reason law codes are so complex and hard to read.
There's another important trick - delegate the actual regulation writing to an agency. That way, the legislator's fingerprints are not anywhere near the actual rules. And, said legislators can also take credit for intervening with the regulators.
You're not going to create any good by looking over someone's shoulder and watching them constantly. You don't do it at work, neither does your boss and neither should your congressman. But what should be happening is we should be measuring their data, their outputs and coming up with systemic, non-politically-charged ways to measure performance and tracking them.
Synopsis: I'm far more interested in supplying the Nate Silver's of the world with more concrete data about Congress than I am having 24 hour video surveillance on Harry Reid.
It's sort of a flaw in democracy that voters will be fully informed about their elected leaders and within one election cycle will be able to judge how effective a leader or congressman turned out to be. An always on-the-record congressman wouldn't make any of that better.