Since there's probably no implementation of any crypto standard that has ever gotten parameter validation right, calling it a "backdoor" is a bit of a stretch.
Since there's probably no implementation of any crypto standard that has ever gotten parameter validation right, calling it a "backdoor" is a bit of a stretch.
No, it's not specifying a particular backdoor, but if you make something hard enough you can be assured one will develop organically. And even if it's not deliberate malfeasance, can we at least call it callous negligence?
'cperciva was on the right track about a better protocol would encode parameters much more simply and have just enough options for an important gamut of use-cases. The issue is we're seemingly stuck on TLS everywhere and would require massive cost and coordination pains to use something, even if it were 10X better and formally-proven.
Yes, these two messages in particular are worth reading:
https://cpunks.org/pipermail/cypherpunks/2015-September/0090...
https://cpunks.org/pipermail/cypherpunks/2015-September/0090...