I remember in particular that the New York Times dumbed down their home page to basically be a bulleted list summary of facts as well as they were known at the time (unfortunately, the web archive doesn't seem to have a copy during the morning of 9/11/2001). And some of those facts were wrong -- a rumor that persisted much longer than others was that there had been a car bomb at the State Dept, but there was a lot of confusion, as well as uncertainty and incredulity about what the truth was.
So, anyway, I like this idea, including the "fog of war" that existed particularly with these events. I don't know what you already have planned, but it would be neat to show both conflicting information in real-time as well as attributing sources (e.g. "CNN is reporting that ...").
Also, another fun event from those years where news outlets screwed everything up would be the 2000 presidential election.