Neil Gaiman recently did a SALT seminar about what makes stories last.
http://longnow.org/seminars/02015/jun/09/how-stories-last/
TLDL - Long-term warnings about phenomena like volcanoes are important for survival, but once the message spans three generations, it's coming from people you don't know, so there's a certain Darwinian quality to the elements of a story that will survive for centuries. This is one reason diverse cultures end up with similar stories.