In our office, I always take the blame jokingly to lighten the mood. It's a running gag, we have three people who are more senior than the others, and we always say "it's his fault, and if not, it's the other one and if not, then it's Leo's fault" (I am the most senior). When a problem arises, it doesn't matter who inserted the bug, but how to fix it the quickest.
These days I mostly use IDEA's annotate feature and don't even know what's the command used in the backend.
[1] http://svnbook.red-bean.com/en/1.6/svn.ref.svn.c.blame.html
But shaped like this, with the name, the graphics, the "whyyyyy" and the overall implication that the commit author had screwed up, it's indeed hostile and counterproductive.
It lets you find the reason why and context in which certain code was added.
[alias] praise = blame
git praise ./path/to/file
git who file
:)