This is what the text says:
>Billy brought along four other developer/designers he was already chatting with: Josh, Clay, Hayden, and another John.
>Our John, Team Paladin John, then went on to introduce ourselves and his idea for us to take 0.4% after helping launch the startup this weekend. That way should anyone go forward with the work product and it become a big success, at least there’s some kickback if this thing goes nuclear unicorn.
Also the way I read
>John explained that he’d spoken with Startup Weekend organizers and was told that contracts aren’t allowed from the event, so he asked for a handshake deal. Billy said he was happy with a handshake deal, and quickly moved the conversation forward without any handshaking actually taking place.
is that this is what everyone implicitly agreed to. I don't find it credible that "I'm happy with a handshake deal" and everyone moving forward isn't evidence of a mutual understanding of what would happen after. The actors acted as if everyone agreed that people would get 0.4% just for participating in the weekend, the terms that were brought to Billy, and that Billy was happy to agree to this.
The fact that these 0.4% terms came from Paladin's camp rather than Billy makes it even more clear that the author is in the wrong.
It sounds to me like you're saying 0.4% has nothing to do with this story whatsoever. It sounds to me like it was agreed on.