Perfect word choice for the article, in my opinion.
Which is, as we've established not what happened.
Also if they were actively deceiving, it would most definitely be a conspiracy.
I've never been a fan of a "pop singer" particularly but isn't that type of fandom more the preserve of teenagers [girls particularly?]?
OT Aside:
>"the intensity of religious faith depends on the notion that prayers are heard by a deity" //
You're clearly off the mark here as some religions don't have a deity but nonetheless have fervent and intense followers.
From the O.E.D.: Charade (2). In extended use: something (esp. a dramatic entertainment) regarded as resembling a charade in some way, esp. in lacking sophistication. Later more usually: an (obvious) deception; an absurd, shallow pretence; a travesty.
I think one would be better off improving one's grasp of English through sources such as The Atlantic than by pretending to have a superior grasp of it.