Wind power is a strange beast. A 300MW wind farm can go from 250MW to 0MW to 100MW over a 1-2 hour period. Trying to properly plan for that or ramping up/down your coal/gas plants to cover the changes is very difficult and expensive.
Wind power is a strange beast. A 300MW wind farm can go from 250MW to 0MW to 100MW over a 1-2 hour period. Trying to properly plan for that or ramping up/down your coal/gas plants to cover the changes is very difficult and expensive.
I can think of a couple of possibilities. Water desalination is an obvious candidate. It might be economical to massively overbuild desalination plants and then only run them at peak capacity when wind is at peak as well. If the cost of electricity is much greater than the capital cost of the desalination plants, then it might be a net win when amortized over the lifetime of the plants.
Generating hydrogen by electrolysis and then immediately converting it to ammonia by the Haber process might be another. The production of ammonia for use in fertilizer using methane as the hydrogen source is a major green house gas contributor. There would be a significant advantage if we could move to carbon-free production.
They are extremely energy intensive: usually operators will only turn them on full when electricity is below e.g. $50 a MW.
The have the added bonus that they can act as a temporary battery: you can smelt extra aluminium to use up the negative energy rates, but then let it convert back again.
I remember it was big news in New Zealand when Tiwai Point (which uses 15% of the power nation wide) shut down some of it's production during the 2008-2009 power shortage (caused by a drought in the hydro power lakes.
Graph: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Electric...
You can also see the other major drought in 1993.
Planned shutdowns are another matter entirely.
In terms of instantaneous interruptible load, wood pulping mills are king. There are some enormous wood chippers in NZ's north island that can be remotely turned on and off by one of the generating companies.
some marketing speak here.
http://energyforindustry.co.nz/experience/interruptible-load...
The large energy cost is in driving the reaction forward.
It seems to me that home battery packs make things like wind power much more attractive because of their ability to smooth out the difference between supply and demand.
I'm not sure why that is dysfunctional. It seems to me like it is compensating for a technical issue?
When looked at from a holistic view, the grid should pay much more for distributed solar production. If it was valued correctly then consumer battery storage would rarely, if ever, make economic sense.
Hawaii have been refusing to allow more solar to be added to the grid, instead of investing on the network upgrades to make it work. Australia are charging high electricity prices for overbuilding the network and not properly valueing the contribution of solar. Various other places are trying to introduce punitive charges for domestic solar. It's good that consumer storage exists as it puts market pressure on these dysfunctional organisations, but decent regulation would have sorted this out properly with far greater efficiency.
I don't know how it could ever not be dysfunctional.
Another interesting development recently was the creation of electric diesel. The economics don't seem to make a lot of sense yet but I don't think they've hit the efficiency limits of what is possible yet. The interesting thing is that it's carbon neutral (assuming the energy going into the process is carbon neutral, e.g. when excess renewable energy drives energy prices negative at moments of the day) probably works on a massive scale, and immediately allows existing fleets of combustion engines to become more sustainable. I'm not sure how fast these factories can turn on and off production but I'm assuming it's pretty good.
The efficiency is pretty low, electricity to diesel I've heard of efficiencies of 13%. And then a diesel engine itself is only about 30% efficient, compared to electric engines of > 90%. It makes more sense to invest in storage solutions and an electric car fleet, but if we do get significant excess renewable energy that is difficult to store, combined with ediesel becoming more efficient, then it becomes an interesting idea. Particularly for all the transport that is hard to electrify (airplanes, trucks), carbon neutral synthetic fuel made with renewable electricity could make sense one day.
I'm mostly optimistic about electrifying cars though. The next-gen top electric cars are getting close to ~100 kwh storage (today it's more like 80-90). Cars per capita in OECD countries is probably around 0.6 - 0.7 or so. That's a lot of storage if fully electrified, about 60-70 kwh per capita. Daily residential electricity usage is probably about 10 kwh in OECD countries. Of course that's when you electrify the entire car fleet which is a ridiculously big task (today's new car sales tend to be sub 1% electric), but if you can do 5% within a few decades, you can create multiple hours of storage which would be a huge impact on the ability to balance intermittent energy sources, without having to invest in storage for the sake of storage.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dynamic_demand_(electric_pow...
Heck, I can think of a lot of uses of power that become practical if the rates are really low. The hot water heater could be heated up a bit extra hot. Ice could be made to supplement the air conditioner during high electric cost times, etc.
All that's needed is variable pricing to the consumer.
There's usually some cost differences for night/day time (or winter/summer) depending on your contract
Now, to have variable pricing for home customers I think the complexity outweighs the advantages (as in, limited capacity to enjoy momentarily cheaper prices)
Then you can set different prices for different things: Don't turn off my AC unless the price exceeds $.50/KWh but stop charging my electric car if it exceeds $.12/KWh.
The power company's problem is that everybody has their AC turned on at 3pm and either the node supplying those houses is overloaded or they must buy energy at crazy spot prices to clear the market.
If they can flip a switch and knock out nearby ACs for 10 minutes then they have time to figure out how to solve the problem before it becomes a blackout.
Now they could "theoretically" introduce a pricing mechanism such that a number of people would shut off their AC due to an increase in price. But that is a lot more complicated (most residences do not do real-time billing for energy, harder to forecast how many users will shut off if price is raised, have to maintain real-time channel for price data) and in practice something will go wrong and you'll blackout instead.
My power in Northern Illinois from nuclear plants run by Exelon is 1 cent per kwh between midnight and 5am due to such low demand. That's pretty close to free.
Doing real-time billing is not a hard technical problem, it's just a one-time cost to replace all the meters.
At that point all you actually need is a standard IP-based protocol to announce real-time rates. The power company doesn't even need to communicate bidirectionally with individual devices whatsoever -- all they need to do is broadcast the current rate and let the devices make choices. Because the choices various devices make will invariably be "when price goes up too much, use less power." So if people are using too much power, you raise the rate a little bit at a time until they no longer are (or the higher rate causes more expensive generation methods to come online).
The only way you get blackouts is if the rate goes so high that every smart device with a cutout is already off and you still don't have enough power, but that's exactly the same failure point as letting the power company turn off your AC. Only worse because if you need some non-standard power company interface with bureaucratic rules instead of a simple standardized rate announcement protocol then there will be fewer smart devices built and purchased that will reduce consumption in response to high rates.
Much easier said than done.
> At that point all you actually need is a standard IP-based protocol to announce real-time rates. The power company doesn't even need to communicate bidirectionally with individual devices whatsoever -- all they need to do is broadcast the current rate and let the devices make choices
Several problems there (before I get into 'kids these days' mode):
- Meter connected 24/7 just to get prices is not feasible (also remember you need per meter pricing for the issues listed by the parent)
- For it to make decisions to "use less power" you need a controller for every device (heating/AC/etc) you want to be controllable - or something more complex if you want fine-grained control
Too complex for home usage, basically, where you want to turn your devices on and not worry about spot pricing
But I'd sign up for variable pricing. I'd need a way to query the internet for the current price. Then, appliances can be set to run when rates are the cheapest. (Electric dryer, hot water heater, refrigerator, dishwasher, car battery charger, etc.)
If they're paying people to dump electricity on them, I can't believe they've got variable pricing for the bulk of their customers.
https://emotorwerks.com/juicebox
It can be set to change when the price is cheapest (on a short timescale, not just an off-peak price) and also to try to minimise the carbon used. It does depend on the local utility offering rebates, but it's often in their narrow financial interests to do so, so the incentives work out.
See also Ice Bear (and competitors) for air-con that stores cheap electricity as ice.
This generally falls under "smart grid" and "demand management" and well designed electric grid markets like in Texas enable these companies to respond to the market price signals.
Many coal and nuclear plants are actually quite good at load following (at least in France and Germany it's common to run nukes in this mode). The units are quite big so they don't have to do that many % per hour in order to keep up with a wind park.
Unfortunately, it doesn't. The big grids such as CAISO (all of California, with wind farms over a range of 500 miles) and PJM (Ohio to the Atlantic Ocean) still routinely see 4:1 variations over the course of a day.
Here's today's CAISO data: Max wind generation: 1350 MW, at 1 AM. Min wind generation: 186MW, at 5 PM.[1] This sucks. At least with solar, you get max output and max air conditioning load at the same time. Getting max wind generation at 1 AM is not too helpful. However, the California Water Project, which is a big power buyer for pumping water uphill, profitably buys late-night cheap power for pumping, then lets water back down through turbines during high-load periods. So some of the big reservoirs double as pumped storage.
Batteries would help. It will take a lot of them. At least 300,000 Tesla Powerwall battery packs would be required to load balance that variation in wind. That's about a billion dollars, which is not unreasonable. When we see wind farms starting to buy batteries in bulk, it will be clear this is working.
But the amount of battery required for reliability is higher than the amount required for improved profitability. Something has to be able to provide power when the wind is calm for a few days, which happens.
[1] http://content.caiso.com/green/renewrpt/20150918_DailyRenewa...
Solar, for example, could be said to have infinite variability since its not available at night, but its actually fairly predicatble if it is spread around geographically.
The price would of course go down for quantity, and putting the individual cells into larger units. Let's wave our hands and say 900M -> 500M.
But per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_Powerwall the $3,000 7kWh daily cycle units have a lifetime of "only" 5,000 cycles. So half "a billion dollars" every 13.5 years, ~100K/day.
It doesn't really make sense to do this with nuclear. Once you've paid the capital cost to construct a nuclear plant, the fuel cost is completely inconsequential and you might as well run it at 100% constantly. Even if you can vary the load you're better off to find something to use the extra capacity for than, essentially, throwing it away.
Of course, that's before politics and market inefficiency. It may be more profitable to reduce supply unnecessarily if it will raise the price per KWh because it's more profitable to generate 900MWh at $.18/KWh than 1000MWh at .04/KWh.