The rise, and rise, of literary annotation
newrepublic.com
newrepublic.com
The ideal scenario is such a thing gets built as free software, implemented non-commercially. Still interested?
Again, I know that personal experience is a bad indicator...but it's not as if I don't want to see more of Genius...I think their mission is great. But while I abhor things like Upworthy and ViralNova and their dozens of other clones...I at least see them in an average week of Internet usage.
Again, not a knock on Genius' mission or execution...Rap songs aside, I think it's inherently hard to get the average reader -- especially today when we seem so much more like a consumer culture than a creator culture -- to casually use the service. I'd even argue that the value of just reading annotations is probably lost on the average Internet user, judging by the vast simplification of reading interfaces/web design that we've seen in all the big content platforms (Twitter, FB, Medium, etc.).
edit: I know it's a little absurd to ask, "Has anyone seen Genius being used?" in a comment thread about a post in which a non-Genius person extols the use of Genius. But with all due respect, the OP is an academic and an editor of a book review...speaking as someone who is also an academic, academics finding something brilliant and edifying is not always an indicator of real-world use.
I think the problem is that people are interested more in individual texts than the platform used for giving them annotations, so it's not really sticky for the typical user.
Also, Genius is a for-profit company that will surely dump literary annotations if they aren't profitable, at which time all of the contributed work will disappear. I expect this contributes to the shallowness/plagiarism of the material: serious users may prefer something like http://hypothes.is/ or a Wikimedia project such as Wikisource, which will care more about preserving information even if it shuts down. (Or their own Word document...)
I think, and hope, someone will make a better product that's not owned by VCs.