What? To me it seems obivous that the right thing to do is have the seatbelt be part of the switch for the airbag -- no seatbelt, no detonation!
What? To me it seems obivous that the right thing to do is have the seatbelt be part of the switch for the airbag -- no seatbelt, no detonation!
It's exactly as insane as it sounds.
However: an airbag isn't very effective (and could even be dangerous) without the seat belt, so manufacturers in Europe aren't really required to worry about the safety without seat belts. Effectively the safety regulations say: those with no seat belts are idiots breaking the law and it's not your job to worry about the safety those people. Which is completely sensible.
I think optional seat belt laws as found in some parts of the US can make some sense there (owing a lot to the fact that there is no single payer healthcare...) BUT the reasonable thing to do would be to not force car manufacturers to make cars less safe for those who do wear seat belts.
The main difference is the force with which they go off. In Europe, it's assumed you're wearing a seatbelt, so the force is less, which results in a lower likelihood of injury, compared to a US airbag. Personally, I prefer the European model - wear a seatbelt and you'll be fine, don't and it's on you.
Personally, I prefer the European model - wear a seatbelt and you'll be fine, don't and it's on you.
The other way around is kind of insane - you increase the risk for everybody who is using their safety equipment properly, for the benefit of those who can't be bothered.Wat? So because the taxpayer isn't directly picking up the healthcare bill, it's somehow okay to double serious crash-related injuries and deaths[1]?
[1] "Seat belts reduce serious crash-related injuries and deaths by about half." http://www.cdc.gov/motorvehiclesafety/seatbelts/facts.html
On the other hand, I believe seat belt usage was still under 50% in the early 1990s [1], when the airbag legislation was being written. (I was born in 1970, and the first time I remember wearing a seatbelt was the summer of ... '85? Getting a ride from a high school friend to football practice every day quickly made me a convert. :) )
[1] http://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/2015/07/30/michigan-se...
But having seat belts for decades and then not expecting people to use them, that's kinda silly.
(cynically, this seems entirely exactly like something Detroit would push for in order to disadvantage imports--so, although this sounds ridiculous, it rings as entirely admissible to me as "no duh" after reading that comment)
I think you're probably in something safer there. The idea behind airbag activation sensors is that you don't want to trigger unnecessary deployments (for a few reasons, but that's a bit involved). That said, depending on the system setup and what type of crash you have, alters which car I'd rather be in.
TL;DR: don't crash.
(This is necessary to pass the annual MOT test here, not just a safety concern - if the OBD interface reports any errors, the car is automatically rejected in the test. Other than that, used Citroëns seem to be fine.)
Dual stage does not mean having the seat weight sensor. That is what is part of what is termed advanced airbag system in US market.
The Volvo system would inflate the airbag less or more rapidly based on force of collision and whether the seat was belted or not. You could have the dealer install a passenger side airbag lock-out though.
There are some horrific crashes in auto racing and the drivers walk away. That convinces me.
I think you may be overlooking an awful lot of what makes modern motor racing safer than it was in the past.
(and that's ignoring the number of serious injuries and driver deaths that still occur thanks to freak accidents)
The first and foremost safety device in a race car is the racing belt. The belt means you slow down with the car, which is much less deceleration than if your body hits the dashboard. (The point of crumple zones in the car is to reduced peak deceleration. In order for that to work, you gotta be strapped in.)
When wearing a 5-point harness without a helmet and head restraint, the deceleration delta between the car and the head will be entirely borne by the structure of the neck, which is how Dale Earnhardt died.
I wonder if the percentage of fatalities from wrecks in auto racing is better or worse that high speed accidents on public highways. It would be an interesting statistic to compare.
That's the important part. Most of the safety devices in a nascar car (or any racing car really) only make sense if you're tightly strapped in the first place. So the first thing is seatbelt, always. Then you can add more stuff protecting the driver under the assumption that the driver's body will move with the car rather than independently within it.
Another anecdote is in order. My father was a fighter jet instructor. The usual arrangement is tandem seating. He related an incident where the jet went off the runway, the nose gear sunk into the mud and the jet went up on its nose.
The guy in back had taken off his shoulder harness while taxiing, but left the helmet and lap belt on. He hit the dash so hard it left his brains splattered all over it, despite having a helmet.
The guy in front left his shoulder harness on, and was uninjured.
My father said that after seeing that, he never unbuckled the harness until the airplane was parked and the engines shut down. He also never moved his car an inch unless everyone in it was buckled up, and this was in the early 1960's long before it was fashionable. I picked up the habit from him :-)
I too think that being buckled-in is the most important, but a 4 or 5 point harness will just not work in a street car. Maybe my best advice is for you to read the relevant sections in the SCCA handbook. Forget about the cage, assume just a cross bar and harness. You will see that it makes it impossible to have the harness at a safe orientation for the driver yet allow a rear passenger. Also when you add the cross bar as it also required, it is now unsafe for a rear passenger.
Further any car with a cage has other compromises and some of those reasons for a cage are for things like being able to quickly jack the car up and rigidity (not just safety) but limits how people can enter and exit for example.
A harness is just not a good fit for a street car. The three point seat belt is an excellent compromise.
Additionally, race cars are designed to essentially disintegrate in hard wrecks -- the cocoon stays intact, but the rest breaks away as a means of absorbing energy. Road cars have a similar design with crumple zones, but race cars take it many steps further.
It's also come to light in the last ~15 years that belts are simply not enough in some instances. Dale Earnhardt (possibly the most famous racer in history) died in an average-looking wreck at Daytona in 2001 because his neck snapped in a collision with the wall; drivers are now required to wear head and neck restraints to prevent this.
Track design plays a role as well. You've probably seen tire walls and gravel traps, but newer technologies -- like SAFER barriers (energy-absorbing walls made of steel and foam) -- have come along and are replacing the old guard.
A roll cage won't do jack for you if you're flying around in the cockpit smashing into the roll cage. Crumple zones are also ineffective if you're not strapped in.
Race cars don't have air bags. If you're strapped in tightly, the air bag adds nothing.
I've been in a crash where the belt saved my life, or at least prevented a crippling injury. I walked away with a broken nose. A roll cage or a HANS without belts would not have helped.
I wonder if that was a factor in the Volvo study.
The crotch strap is to prevent your body from submarining out from under the lap belt.
https://www.quora.com/Motorsports/Is-MotoGP-more-dangerous-t...
Race tracks don't have most of those hazards, and control most of the pedestrian hazards, with the limited pedestrians on the hot side of the pit wall assuming much of the responsibility for their own safety.
This would be offset by a reduction in head injuries (with a possible increase in neck and spinal injuries). I think I'd bet a full study would show an overall decrease in safety.
The first thing anyone says in a small ish accident (especially as a cyclist/motorcyclist) is SORRY MATE DIDN'T SEE YOU THERE
So imagine that blocking a good section of your forward vision, and a helmet blocking anything to the sides... motorcycles have very small blind spots as the rider can swivel anywhere with no cage blocking them. Helmets are a minor contributor. But cars don't have that luxury.
Sadly never made it to production.
Which is why the research into this topic focuses more on headbands, which mostly protect the forehead, than the entire head. See http://www.copenhagenize.com/2009/10/australian-helmet-scien... for a summary of Australian research and a sketch of the head gear. They quote:
> But more impressive were the estimates of introducing protective headwear for car occupants. The authors of the report estimated that the annual reduction in harm would be in the order of $380 million. The benefit of padding the head is that the head is protected from strikes with unpadded automotive components, exterior objects and in vehicles that predate any eventual introduction of padded interiors."
I don't know if you can legally install one to replace your 3 point by choice, but if you mandated them I suspect seat belt usage would plummet, which seems counterproductive.
For that matter, mandated helmet usage would improve many types of injuries, but I don't see that flying either.
From a public safety point of view, many of these decisions are more about balancing compliance and safety, rather than safety alone.