Matlab's strength is doing lots of things for you through its toolboxes; Sage Math is a bloated monster, Maxima is pretty damn good, haven't spent any time with Axiom. Octave is pretty good (none of those delicious toolboxes though) and Scilab just 'felt' wrong (and its Simulink knockoff was atrocious). Mathcad is great, but also expensive and closed - Mathworks kneecapped them by buying the company that made their symbolic engine (and turning it into a toolbox/addon for Matlab).
OpenModelica I never got far with, but I'd like to do some multidomain simulation with eventually.
If I missed a good CAS, let me know.