I don't want to live in a society where government regulation leads to financial disaster for individuals, and the society and government response is "tough luck".
I don't want to live in a society where government regulation leads to financial disaster for individuals, and the society and government response is "tough luck".
I cannot live in a society where profits get concentrated when things go well and losses get spread around when things don't, because that is not a sustainable society.
For example, if I pay for rights to drill for oil somewhere and oil becomes obsolete, should I be reimbursed by my competitors?
The upside potential of one of these medallions was unlimited. After buying it once, you could use it to make an unbounded amount of money. Part of that is accepting the risk that it might make no money. Otherwise you're asking the rest of society to subsidize a private interest.
Therefore, it is well known that both a) regular property and b) medallions can lose value from either 1) governments not enforcing exclusivity or 2) legal alternatives becoming better. Governments never made any promise (either for property or medallions) that thy wouldn't lose value from 2). (To extend the analogy further to the car dealership case, the manufacturer makes no promises about eg Chevy demand falling because public transit gets better.)
To be sure, it certainly does suck when you put all your net worth in one asset and it loses value, but it does not thereby follow that your rights were violated or that a promise was broken. Nor does it necessarily make sense for the government to spread out the losses from this, because, well, why stop there? Why not socialize the losses from tepid real estate markets for leveraged homeowners, or for leveraged investors in local industries when their foreign counterparts get better?
There isn't a lot you can do about limiting investment downside risk beyond preventing people from having too much net worth in any one thing ... which maybe they should have done for medallions (or should start doing for homes, for that matter).