The Future of Language
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
I don't mean this as a middlebrow dismissal -- I am not very knowledgeable about Chinese and I am hoping someone has a good explanation for this. For example, maybe it's the case that everyone speaks their local language and a unified dialect as well; or maybe it's that the vast majority of people all speak one dialect (Mandarin?) such that these articles are only counting those people; or maybe it's some other thing I don't understand.
Also the written language, which varies far less, has always served as sort of an anchor and connecting point.
Historically, language was one of the central factors underlying the entire concept of "China" and "Chinese" (China as a country in the modern sense is a very recent phenomena).
The by-now ancient joke is that a "language is a dialect with an army and navy".
Less jokingly, the different Chinese "dialects" share a written language, as above, but the other spoken "dialects" are largely unintelligible to those who have been exposed to only one of those spoken "dialects".
That's actually not true. Modern written Chinese is pretty much Mandarin Chinese. You can pronounce written Chinese with a non-Mandarin dialect but most of the times that is not how the dialect is spoken, and if you write the spoken form of a non-Mandarin dialect, there is a good chance that a lot of pieces of it won't make sense to someone who doesn't speak that dialect, on top of the fact that most dialects don't have a standardized written form in Chinese Characters. Most people speaking two different dialects can communicate via characters because they have learned written Mandarin.
Adding to what you said (and correct me if I'm wrong here, this is based on some quick research [1]), while written Mandarin is by far the most common - and official - writing system, most dialects have completely different sets (i.e. non-1-to-1 mappings) of words than Mandarin, and many have supplemental character sets that wouldn't make any sense to someone reading Mandarin. The Hong Kong Supplementary Character Set, for instance, is a set of characters that are specific to the Cantonese dialect, and don't have close/exact relatives in standard written Mandarin [2]. Additionally, while the grammar of the different dialects seem rather close (similar to the relationships between Romance languages), the number of syllables used to represent vocabulary varies from dialect to dialect, which suggests vastly different etymology between the dialects. What I find particularly interesting is that given these substantial differences in vocabulary, one's native spoken language and one's native written language can be at odds with one another. Perhaps this is mitigated by the fact that spoken Mandarin is so widespread, but I wonder how this affects written communication for those who don't speak Mandarin natively.
[1] https://www.quora.com/Linguistically-speaking-how-similar-ar...
Yes, that is correct. Cantonese is probably the non-Mandarin dialect with the most writing going on, and that is mostly informal writing like facebook, blogs, gossip magazines, although there is some modern literature written in Cantonese characters, wikipedia in Cantonese probably counts as well for more formal writing.
>> The Hong Kong Supplementary Character Set, for instance, is a set of characters that are specific to the Cantonese dialect, and don't have close/exact relatives in standard written Mandarin
Yes, though I don't know if there are Unicode code points for all the Cantonese characters. You often see this like o的,o個,o即 instead of 啲,嗰,嘅. I know a lot of people in Hong Kong use Cangjie for character input and a lot of the Cantonese characters don't have (or didn't have) Cangjie mappings.
>> I wonder how this affects written communication for those who don't speak Mandarin natively
When speaking Taiwanese it is common to use Mandarin words for more educated topics or if you don't know the word in Taiwanese just use the Mandarin term. Probably because Taiwanese is not generally used in higher education and there are varying levels of Taiwanese fluency in Taiwan. I would imagine it's similar for a lot of dialects in China since speaking dialects is often discouraged and a lot of younger people abandon their native dialects.
A linguistic survey conducted by the P.R.C. regime discloses that barely more than half the population of China is conversant in the standard form of Mandarin.[1] Of course younger persons rather than older, and urban persons rather than rural, are more likely to be able to communicate with one another in standard Mandarin ("Putonghua"), but there are many people who have a need to communicate by speech who cannot. Contrary to much myth about the issue, I have NEVER seen two Chinese persons who cannot speak a mutually comprehensible language resort to writing out Chinese characters for one another in an attempt at conversation. To the contrary, I have seen many more examples of Chinese people (some from one place, some from another in China) speaking to one another in English as a useful interlanguage, although these days most people who can do that can also use Putonghua as an interlanguage.
Chinese characters still represent SPEECH (not ideas or abstract concepts) and do so in a way that is specific to the particular Chinese (Sinitic) language that one speaks. The long story about this can be found in the books The Chinese Language: Fact and Fantasy[2] or Visible Speech: The Diverse Oneness of Writing Systems[3] by the late John DeFrancis or the book Ideogram: Chinese Characters and the Myth of Disembodied Meaning[4] by J. Marshall Unger. The book Reading in the Brain: The Science and Evolution of a Human Invention[5] by Stanislas Dehaene is a very good book about reading in general, and has a good cross-cultural perspective.
I'll give an example here of how Chinese characters reflect speech more than they reflect meaning-as-such. Many more examples are possible. How you might write the conversation
"Does he know how to speak Mandarin?
"No, he doesn't."
他會說普通話嗎?
他不會。
in Modern Standard Chinese characters contrasts with how you would write
"Does he know how to speak Cantonese?
"No, he doesn't."
佢識唔識講廣東話?
佢唔識。
in the Chinese characters used to write Cantonese. As will readily appear even to readers who don't know Chinese characters, many more words than "Mandarin" and "Cantonese" differ between those sentences in Chinese characters.
Many other examples of words, phrases, and whole sentences that are essentially unreadable to persons who have learned only Modern Standard Chinese can be found in texts produced in Chinese characters by speakers of other Sinitic languages ("Chinese dialects"). Similar considerations apply to Japanese, which is not even a language cognate with Chinese, and also links Chinese characters to particular speech morphemes (whether etymologically Japanese or Sino-Japanese) rather than with abstract concepts.
[1] http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2007-03/07/content_5812838...
[2] http://www.amazon.com/Chinese-Language-Fantasy-John-DeFranci...
[3] http://www.amazon.com/Visible-Speech-Asian-Interactions-Comp...
[4] http://www.amazon.com/Ideogram-Chinese-Characters-Disembodie...
It's worth noting that Chinese itself uses a different terminology to distinguish between different Chinese languages versus non-Chinese languages (and the same term for what modern linguists would call distinct dialects versus distinct languages)--this is often translated as "dialect," although "variety" is probably a better translation today.
In practice, most Chinese speak Mandarin (Wikipedia lists ~70% of native-language, and I think I recall seeing 90% if second language is included), and the Chinese government itself actively discourages schools (both inside and outside the country) from trying to teach non-Mandarin variants. For all intents and purposes, "Chinese language" and "Mandarin" can be used interchangeably (with the former being preferred to the lay person). It's a bit like calling Prussia of the 1700s and 1800s Germany: it's not quite correct, but the difference is small enough that it's usually not worth arguing over.
I wonder if a better statistic would be number of speakers with working knowledge of a language, weighted by GDP per capita of the countries in which those speakers live. Of course, that assumes the purpose of learning a language is to do business, which is not necessarily true.
I know that Wikipedia can't be taken as The Truth, but a quick search on Internet seems to get values closer to 200-300M than to 450M (except for Ulrich Ammon, which is the source for the post). It seems a sensible difference, anyone has an explanation?
For example, in [1], the total (L1 + L2) is 490 M. The total for English is 840M, then, not ~500M, which is L2. The primary source is this [2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_num...
I say almost artificial because it has never been any body's native language at any point in time.
Now, Classical Arabic, theoretically was the native language of certain tribes in the Hijaz region (of modern day Saudi Arabia) some 1400 years ago. Standard Arabic is a modernized version of Classical Arabic. Some vocabulary have almost completely different meanings, and a large number of modern collocations would probably make no sense to the native speakers of Classical Arabic if they were alive today.