Are there any sane, evidence-based criticisms? Because Common Core seems like a decent improvement to me.
Are there any sane, evidence-based criticisms? Because Common Core seems like a decent improvement to me.
Problem is they make the kids draw out this giant ridiculous diagram every time, and they get graded on whether they draw the picture error free. So instead of teaching the concept and then reinforcing the application of the concept they are reinforcing how well you can draw the needless picture you were taught. Parents then get mad because they can't help their kids because they didn't learn the rules of the diagram drawing.
Every other criticism is consistent with your experience, essentially calling it overreaching or teachers complaining that they shouldn't have to learn it to teach their kids.
[1] http://www.thefederalistpapers.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/0... (this was the first Google hit for the image I was looking for)
Which is how almost every engineer I know would do the math in their head. If they didn't just go "30 - 10 or roughly 20" (obviously most engineers can do that simple a subtraction completely--but the number of times I estimate something by lopping off everything except the leading digit is quite high).
Note that this is teaching "estimation" almost by osmosis. The "standard" procedure of starting from the least significant digit and "borrowing" obscures estimation.
Yes, seems Common Core is trying to teach those methods - but to children who barely grasp the subject, and thus must memorize rote processes to scribble down all the obligatory steps without understanding why they're doing it.
Children need learn math by concrete manipulatives, handling the physical-world form until they (individually!) internalize the process, then growing comfortable enough with those internalized processes to develop more sophisticated AND casual ways to mentally tear numbers apart & rearrange them to perform calculations fast.
The rote processes Common Core teaches are closer to what you and I use. Why teach subtraction from least-significant to most significant manipulation and then make students throw that away and relearn the other direction? That is especially meaningless when tabular clerical calculation skills have no existence in the modern world.
We don't teach children to read from right to left and then force them to relearn reading left to right to read fast.
> Children need learn math by concrete manipulatives, handling the physical-world form until they (individually!) internalize the process, then growing comfortable enough with those internalized processes to develop more sophisticated AND casual ways to mentally tear numbers apart & rearrange them to perform calculations fast.
And, yet, most significant to least significant is almost always how we manipulate things in the real world.
I cut material down to rough size, and then I cut it to detailed length. Imperial recipes measure multiple cups and then fractional cups. A bolt looks like a 1/2 inch head, so I try the sockets around my estimate. etc.
Better reading analogy [I read very fast]: we don't teach children to glance at a page, absorb random words, predict likely filler content, identify interesting sections, and repeat process on those sections - instead, we teach children to read left-to-right, word-for-word, until they can do so well enough & fast enough that they internally develop content prediction techniques leading to "page at a glance" reading.
No such thing. Common Core doesn't specify methods, it specifies that students must attain specific things by specific times. Methods are left up to individual districts, as they have always been.
I'm a away from my desk, but the examples that are causing the most problems are not the ones shown in the referenced article (those seem quite reasonable). The problem is how they teach addition and multiplication. Basically they are trying to do abacus math without the abacus. They also accept estimates instead of actual answers and a total removal of the memorizing of tables. A buddy of mine who is an EE with a heavy math background has had trouble helping his child get the correct answer. The worst part is he taught his daughter math early and she struggles because she knows the answer but doesn't know how to express it the way her teacher wants. This is a true pain because he thought he was raising a kid excited about STEM and now its just a wall.
As to the state rights and such. Yes, that is a valid issue, but is much broader than Common Core and a continuation of lunches and NCLB. Common Core is just more evidence to an old argument.
My kids both had abacuses at their desks in Elementary school.
> They also accept estimates instead of actual answers
I haven't seen this at all. Like any math class, partial credit is given if the method was sound but there were arithmetic errors.
> a total removal of the memorizing of tables.
This has nothing to do with the Common Core, and was a decision made by the school. Both of my kids have numerous tools at their disposal, from the school, and mastery of basic math facts up to 12 is required as part of my daughter's second grade competency.
You're conflating a lot of different things under the umbrella of "Common Core." When was the last time you went to a school board meeting?
Yeah, and I'm not sure that is a good thing http://www.ee.ryerson.ca/~elf/abacus/feynman.html
> I haven't seen this at all.
I have and the estimate is what was supposed to be the answer given, not the actual answer. This causes stress in parents and children who know math.
> You're conflating a lot of different things under the umbrella of "Common Core." When was the last time you went to a school board meeting?
Never went, also a school board meeting is not the be all and end all of the standard. I have a nephew and niece coming up and have seen the homework of my peer's children. Also, I've read the standard http://www.corestandards.org/wp-content/uploads/Math_Standar...
Yeah, these anecdotes of supposedly brilliant people incapable of learning a new way to add numbers are always about engineers and accountants and stuff. Never an actual mathematician. It's almost like they went through an entire college degree pushing symbols and were never forced to stop and come up with a real proof on their own...
It's possible to have a heavy math background and still be shit at math. Especially if that background stopped short of anything proof-based (but even then, plenty of people memorize proof techniques instead of actually understanding the arguments and the subject).
Calculus sequences and ODEs courses that EEs take are particularly bad. They are just symbol pushing like in middle and high school. More symbols and more complicated pushing, but nothing essentially deeper.
If I had a dime for every vector calculus student who didn't understand basic facts about the Reals (or even the Integers)... and most of them get decent marks, too.
So, new rule: any rant about common core mathematics can only contain as many words as the number of words in the longest proof the speaker has written outside the context of a homework assignment or exam.
No, he is "not shit at math", he loves it, tried to pass that love on, got that dream promptly resisted, and you don't make the rules. Anecdotes and narratives are valuable. Looking at a lot of these studies, they are just gussied up anecdotes with questionable method and results.
But when those anecdotes and narratives are ultimately nothing more or less than an appeal to authority ("I'm an ENGINEER/accountant/etc. and can't do/didn't do/don't need to do this -- it must be crap!"), then it's absolutely reasonable to question that authority.
What, exactly, was the problem that your friend had trouble finding the correct answer to?
I'm extremely skeptical claims with the form "I'm an X and can't do CC problems" for a reason. There's no shortage of anti-common-core accountants/engineers/etc. who take the the blogosphere with complaints that "even they" don't know how to work a problem.
But when you look at the problem, it's just performing addition using a non-standard algorithm or setting up and solving for a linear relationship. Not exactly rocket science. And then you look at Calc III classrooms and see students who clearly haven't internalized division. Which leaves only one conclusion -- being an engineer or accountant who made it through a few calc courses doesn't exactly equate to "good problem solver" or "understands anything about mathematics".
> Looking at a lot of these studies, they are just gussied up anecdotes with questionable method and results.
I'm not really sure what you're talking about here.
I don't need empirical evidence that understanding multiple algorithms for a arithmetic procedures is a useful and crucial exercise. Just like I don't need empirical evidence do know that there's a lot less value in memorizing quick sort than there is in seeing multiple different sorting algorithms and comparing them.
> and you don't make the rules
Obviously :-) But it's a good sanity check on what it means to be well-trained in mathematics.
If you've never written a proof of substantial length, you really don't know what mathematics actually is. In particular, the mathematics courses US engineers and accountants take are mostly unsubstantiated symbol pushing (warrant: find me a calculus student in the US outside of Chicago or a few other places who can prove the fundamental theorem), which isn't mathematics.
Common Core is based on a bunch of studies, look up the list cited in the documents on it.
> If you've never written a proof of substantial length, you really don't know what mathematics actually is. In particular, the mathematics courses US engineers and accountants take are mostly unsubstantiated symbol pushing (warrant: find me a calculus student in the US outside of Chicago or a few other places who can prove the fundamental theorem), which isn't mathematics.
When you decide that only one place in the US has any idea what mathematics is, then this discussion is not going to go any further. I guess Harvard, MIT, etc. don't count.
I'm not an educational researcher and I don't have a thorough understanding of the research methodology or the issues involved in designing those studies. Every Education researcher I've talked to thinks anti-common core people are a bit nuts and/or fundamentally don't understand what common core even is (I think most of them would put you in this second camp, since you're complaining about specific assignments).
But as a mathematician, some problems are obviously the sort of problems that anyone with a passable mathematics education should have no problem solving. The common core problems people complain about are decidedly in this set.
So when people say "I can't solve this common core problem", I mostly take it as an indication that they've had a really shitty mathematics education rather than an indication that common core is flawed.
And yes, even someone who has passed through a calc course at Harvard can be bad at math.
> I guess Harvard, MIT, etc. don't count.
Harvard, MIT, etc. have excellent Mathematics departments and, following my criteria, any Math major for either of those institutions could have a lengthy conversation about common core. Indeed, among the many mathematicians I know with undergraduate degrees from Harvard College, I've never heard a single one complain that common core problems are obtuse or difficult.
The distinction I was drawing is that US-based Calculus for Engineers and ODEs for Engineers courses aren't proof-based except in a small handful of cases. And, those courses are often easy to skate through with little or no mathematical understanding. Yes, even at elite universities.
Which goes back to my original observation -- if you really can't add numbers in a novel way or setup and solve for a set of linear equations, then you're apparently not very good at math. Even if you are an intelligent pattern matcher who made it through a few calc courses by applying templates and performing rote calcuations.
Why is that a valid issue?
And the other side will state that it's covered by the commerce clause or general welfare clause or something. (But everything can be argued to be covered by those to clauses, and the 10th Amendment meant something to the authors...)
These are more implementation problems, but as a parent they've been the biggest issue.
In contrast "Integrated Learning 1" by CPM takes a very different approach. It is very much continuous where the "text" of a topic is interwoven with a couple problems to do. Class room exercises and experiments constitute a lot of the main lessons. This is in contrast to Khan Academy where the progression of math knowledge is easily understandable and the step-by-step approach for learning by example and doing is emphasized.
I was a bit taken aback by this approach. I can see it possibly working better in a class room setting. However I did most of my learning by reading. I'm also concerned that this approach will make it more difficult for students to catch up if their previous math education was not great as this continuous flow style doesn't lay out which topics to study.
I'm not sure, but I'm not currently convinced. I'll be seeing how my younger sibling fares next semester, especially as our parents are not great at math and his education has some large holes in it (which we are working on). Thankfully he really enjoys Khan Academy so I anticipate him using that more if Common Core falls short.
None of that has anything to do with Common Core, and, AFAICT, politically, the groups that most oppose Common Core are the groups that have most supported the policies that have done the most to produce the effects you complain about.
The biggest problem with common core is that it codifies social promotion under the guise of "schools know better" while linking promotion to money received by the schools.