Syllables without vowels?
daily.jstor.org
daily.jstor.org
I once had a frustrated student talk to me about a Japanese colleagues pronunciation. He said words like "fight" with the stereotypical vowel tacked onto the end so they became "fighto". I explained that Japanese is divided up in units like ka, bu, to and so on. The student replies "Why doesn't he just say the first half of 'to'?" to which I replied "Try saying the first half of 'b'".
A blunter way of putting it is "I will accept any criticisms of Dr. Yamada's English ability if you're capable of articulating them in Japanese." or "How's your Japanese?", both of which I've had regrettable need to use in professional contexts before.
[+] Fellow linguists will know this is an abuse of jargon but it's the easiest way to communicate the concept to someone who isn't a linguist.
I watched an english teacher once convince a (native english-speaking) student that "handbag" is always pronounced as "hambag". This is not entirely true, but close enough that I wouldn't really object to it. I objected quite strongly to the method of convincing, which was to make the following argument:
1. /m/ is pronounced by closing the lips, whereas /n/ is not
2. OK, watch this other student articulate "handbag". Other student, please say "handbag".
Even if you articulate the word so carefully that you release the /d/ of handbag, your lips will close immediately afterwards when you pronounce /b/. This style of arguing, we're better off without.
Just not with any other consonant.
This confuses my gaijin brain.
(Also, the first half of "b" is "m'". :-P)
>(this can be easily disproven by an example of Japanese person who speaks English fluently, which clearly exist)
All this proves is the individuals who can speak English fluently are capable. Not necessarily that others are also capable, thus this isn't a proof.
I do agree they are physically capable of making the sound, but this argument isn't why and isn't convincing. Especially not to my teacher who maintains that others are capable but she is incapable. So this argument can also be considered potentially "harmful" for learners' self esteem and willingness to fall down 7 times, get up 8.
Following the same rules, "I meet" is pronounced "ntmpin" (spelled întâmpin), and "song" is pronounced "cnt" (spelled cânt).
"...these types of syllables, astonishingly, really do not contain any vowels, epenthetic or otherwise"
when in fact, there clearly is an epenthetic vowel after the s.
The article addresses exactly this point, and acknowledges that plenty of other linguists already argued for it. The counter argument is "I fed this into a spectral analyzer, and there are no vowels on the spectrograph." Care to claim your ears are more accurate than the computer?
E.g. in some West and South Slavic languages 'r' can be a syllable or its core, while in Polish it underwent a transformation into 'er' or 'rz' + vowel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stress_and_vowel_reduction_in_...
prst: finger
tvrd: hard
krv: blood
hrt: greyhound
smrt: death
trp: sea cucumber
krt: without fat (e.g. meat)
trk: act of runningIn Devanagari, an abugida that makes a clear distinction between vowels and consonants, there are r and l vowels.
A continuant in a vocalic position in a syllable is a vowel. A continuant in a consonantal position is a consonant. We see this in the opposite direction in English with word-initial 'w' and 'y', both are continuants that make a sound that could, in a vocalic position, likely be represented by one or more of the aforementioned vowels of the Roman alphabet.
Non-continuants cannot occupy vowel positions, and there are no examples of this in the article.
Even where, orthographically, a syllable is represented by a grapheme typically considered to represent a stop consonant (e.g. k in Slovak), this will normally represent the consonant and an unwritten vowel (e.g. a following schwa).
Only time when "k" changes into "ku" is if the next word start with k, g, q or x: ku Karolovi, ku Gustavovi, ku Quidovi, ku Xylofónu
It is not added to previous or next word, but if you speak fast it would sound like m'lady in english.
I don't have microphone here I'll check the waveform later.
Previous word ending has no effect whatsoever: zemiak k mäsu - potato to meat (although in this case with Assimilation it may be pronounced as "zemiak g mäsu" or "zemiak g'mäsu")
In the article the mention Tashlhiyt Berber but then they put an example that actually HAS VOWELS.
In "ssrksxt" there are not vowels in the script, but there are vowels in the sound. I can hear at least two of them.
The fact that you don't write it down does not mean that it does not exist.
For example in English "spoken" is pronounced like ES- POU -KEN(1), even when there is no "e" in the first S, actually the "e" vowel exist in the sound, and you use two pure sounds when there is only one "o" in the middle.
On the other hand, vowels that exist on script does not need to exist in sound. The typical example is Make, wich actually sounds like MEIK.
(1)If we consider pure vocal sounds as in Japanese, Spanish or Turkish. English ha no clear sounds for vowels, but mixes pure sounds.
This isn't true, but Spanish speakers will pronounce it that way. Spanish doesn't allow sk- or sp- clusters at the beginning of words, so you can see exactly what the phenomenon you describe sounds like.