Apple’s 3D Touch Is the Start of a New Interface
wired.com
wired.com
The problem is further compounded by 3D Touch not really having an obvious use case in most apps. What it'll do will vary from app to app. That means a user has to learn what it does over and over again, and how much pressure to use in each thing. What 'light touch' is in one developer's app will be different to another's.
3D Touch is great, and has loads of potential, but it's going to be hard to make it genuinely useful.
I have no idea what that would look like, but on a random note, a bubble wrap popping game with 3D touch support would be dope.
I've found the popup previews surprisingly useful across applications after expecting it to purely be a gimmick. It's especially useful on HN and other text heavy sites with links. I'm interested to see if web designers start designing for such previews - at the moment a lot sites previews are their banner adverts or other non-content related fluff. It'd be quite useful if you could make Safari popup previews in its reader mode to remove non-content items.
The the "if it's not flat it makes me physically ill!" school of designers got ahold of it...
I see one big exception and that is games. Phones are limited when it comes to controls and 3D Touch can be a welcome addition. Discoverability isn't as much of a problem for games, because there is usually a tutorial anyway.
Of course, it will be a while before games will be designed around 3D touch, because older iPhones and Android phones.
Those new interactions will always only be the equivalent of keyboard shortcuts. Nothing more.
3D touch does resolve the iOS issue of not having a back button(without adding any of the ambiguity I hope). I sincerely doubt regular users would use it. It would be like multitasking or the does cool 4-finger gestures on the iPad, something only power-users use extensively.
Not saying it's right or wrong, just stating a fact.
It means "rearrange". For example apps on the home screen, movies in my streaming app etc.
Deleted comment
A) immediate graduated feedback (perhaps a learning point for pressure sensitive interfaces here?)
B) is something that you have to learn to do well (an awful lot of people never do - most people aren't artists.)
All I was really pointing out that pressure sensitivity isn't an unusual concept. I'd be quite surprised if people didn't use it in a variety of situations each day.
While I agree that most people would understand the concept of pressure sensitive interfaces. It's not clear to me that people have much practice with them, nor that what little practice many of them do have equips them to be particularly skilled with the things.
By way of illustration: can you imagine someone who hasn't learned to use a computer before learning on an interface such as this? It's hard enough reminding people that you choose the right mouse button to access particular parts of the interface, now you have to remind them that you press this button but only this hard (how do you even give them the knowledge of how hard to push to access the damn thing?) And it's not particularly discoverable, a lot of people don't even discover the right click menu for themselves, when there's a button just sitting there for them to press to find that out.
I don't think it would occur to people that the system would be expected to function in that way. Most of our tools don't seem to. Those that do manage to do so, and to do so well, seem to have extremely short feedback cycles between the use of input and the desired output state of the activity. It's possible that you might make a menu fade in, as someone presses harder on the screen to try to shorten the feedback cycle. That would make it more discoverable and allow people to work out how hard they need to press. The problem there would be that the menu would start showing up during routine use, (because if you made it only show up when someone pressed hard, it would have the same limitations of being on discoverable as the other system had.) Perhaps people would just get used to such a system, but I can see it being extremely frustrating to have a menu fade in as you were scrolling through a web page.
Sure, I can preview a link in Safari or Mail, but what about when someone posts a link on Facebook or Messenger, I can't deep press on it to preview that link. So right now, everything is pretty fragmented. Do I want to try to deep press on something to see if it supports it? If not, I have to lift the finger and just tap it again.
Until everything supports it, I just won't find it natural. Right now it's pretty much hit or miss.
Unlike many Android device manufacturers (except maybe Samsung if they were to focus for once and not be so overwhelmingly complex in all the stuff they put into their phones) Apple is in a unique position to actually teach people about this through marketing. And they will. They will teach people about it, devs will be on board real quick and it will just become a natural interaction. That's my prediction.
Apple at the end of January, and Samsung at the end of February.
I also noticed that the Android API has had a getPressure[3] call since really early API versions, so I assume they were aware this was an option a long time ago.
Any ideas why this is suddenly being touted as "the Start of a New Interface"? Has the accuracy / latency / sensitivity finally become good enough to be useful? Or is this just the Apple PR juggernaut pushing an old idea as a new feature?
[1]: http://pdfaiw.uspto.gov/.aiw?docid=20140028575
[2]: http://pdfaiw.uspto.gov/.aiw?docid=20140055407
[3]: http://developer.android.com/reference/android/view/MotionEv...
>the biggest interface innovation since multitouch.
Seriously ? I don't get the interest around 3d Touch. As long as the action is not immediately discoverable, it is not going to be used by most of your users. long press or nav drawers perform pretty badly, how is 3d touch any different ?
"Press this, no, hmm try harder, no not that hard, no the other one you need to press lightly, wait maybe that's too light..."
Some things obviously lend themselves well to this. The piano example is good, as is drawing. However, things with a threshold sound less obvious.
> “There was a physical thing on the screen,” he says. “You had to select the button and move it over.” It was better than the existing ideas, sure, but what was that button? It moved too freely, you didn’t know how it would move or how to make it stop.
You didn't know how it would move or how to make it stop? Really?
It's very well thought out. This is all about the software implementation. Pressure sensitive screens by themselves are boring tech.
"That’s technical speak for, it’s rock solid, it’s
totally accurate. You probably could build a sail
using that stuff." - Georg Petschnigg, CEO of FiftyThree
Can anyone explain that quote? I don't understand the "build[ing] a sail" part. I've never heard that before.Is building a sail some kind of delicate, nuanced process? I guess it relates back to pressure somehow?
It seems like carefully controlling the strength of your touch - or for that matter, pressing hard at all - could be outside of the capabilities of some disabled users. I've got slightly poor control over my hands and that already makes it rather difficult to use some mobile apps and games.
And you can adjust the sensitivity of 3D touch so it should be easier to use than typical long presses.
I use Alt-Tab, it works on Linux Mint and Windows, I like hacky workarounds, I don't like when things change.
That said, 3D Touch is the best thing since Multitouch? Well except zooming nobody of my non-technical friends here ,could give me any usecase for using more than one finger. If anything with touch, I would need a keyboard that I actually can use.
Too bad the tech isn't there yet :(
Anyone know why that is? I thought it was the same tech.
I have a MacBook Pro with Force Touch and honestly haven't used it much yet. I think it's for the same reason as another poster says. I'm not sure where it's available and what it will do? In safari it previews links and gives definitions.
The preview links thing is a bit redundant because clicking a link and swiping back is just as fast.
You can change the sensitivity settings but they will always be different.
Marketing terms are used constantly for referring to specific flavours of technology. For example, Google Now, Cortana and Siri. Language and people are flexible enough to cope with multiple terms for a technology. Also, it's faster to type than "microphone which samples and uploads to an external voice processing server which returns system commands".