Nuclear Forensics Shows Nazis Were Nowhere Near Making Atomic Bomb
cen.acs.org
cen.acs.org
As I understand it, the Nazi regime never got to the point of even realizing that a bomb was a serious possibility. So naturally, they never devoted real resources to figuring out the details and how to go about actually building one.
There's also the economic aspect - the initial development work was massively expensive, and even the other major WWII combatants who had an idea that a bomb was possible didn't think they would be able to devote enough resources to it to actually build one for that war. They may well have been right - even with the massive resources the US poured into the project, the war was still pretty close to being over before they had a bomb ready to drop.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frisch%E2%80%93Peierls_memoran...
The centrepiece is a curated set of transcripts from secret recordings of the candid conversations of a group of German scientists detained together for months after the war (specifically for the purpose of surveilling such conversations).
Some vaguely YC-ish lessons on how their failure to produce could be attributed in many ways to seemingly mundane organizational structures that were debatably inherent to Nazi German society and internal politics.
Also some borderline pornographic payoff when they find out about Hiroshima. At the time, they were convinced they were 10 years ahead of anyone else, and were being detained as a prelude to being showered with honours and put in place to bring American and British science into the modern age. Then they set about convincing themselves they failed on purpose for moral reasons.
That's what the plutonium path is all about. It doesn't require a lot, and between the uranium ore from Africa they got when the captured Belgium, and the not as rich ore from Czechoslovakia, it was judged it might be enough.
You say it's "inconceivable", but it was indeed "conceived", considered to be possible, if perhaps unlikely, by lots of scientists and engineers working on the Manhattan Project. Who as it progressed had a better and better idea of exactly what was required. And who knew how long we dicked around with the concept before committing to it, and then putting Groves in charge.
There's also the danger of 20/20 hindsight. For example, the critical March 1940 Frisch–Peierls memorandum (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frisch%E2%80%93Peierls_memoran...) laid out the scientific path to success (fast fission) and estimated about 1 kg (2.2 lb) of U-235 was required. Later it was learned it was 52 kg, and plutonium-239 a much more modest 10 kg. Suppose the universe instead allowed 1 pound of Pu-239? Is that still "inconceivable"?
Was the V-2 effort "inconceivable"? It required a similar order of magnitude of effort, we knew more about the project because they had to test fly it, the threat was obvious and it did cause a lot of harm, and yet the "risk by air" was not enough to take it out prior to that harm.
The final detail is that even if low priority (you're not going to convince many it was truly impossible), the consequences of their getting it before it was too late for the Third Reich were ... well, it would have been existential for them.
The final detail is that even if low probability (you're not going to convince many it was truly impossible), the consequences of their getting it before it was too late for the Third Reich were ... well, it would have been existential for them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shinkolobwe
Nobody else had the raw materials in such a useful form. I say this is the quirk of history that gets overlooked when it comes to the race to get the bomb.
I remember reading somewhere that the abundance of electricity in the US led its planners to ignore the fragility of Axis power infrastructure when selecting targets for strategic bombing. Allied dam busting was tactical and carried out by medium bombers at low level not the heavies from altitude used on targets deemed important.
This was on both sides, so you had things like how none of the German bombs ever managed to hit a 'royal' palace, e.g. the one that German lady lives in with postcode SW1A 1AA.
Meanwhile, the train tracks that led to the concentration camps were miraculously spared from the Allied bombing campaigns.
From the perspective of the arms companies, why bomb something like a power plant when you could expend far more ordnance wiping out working class populations?
Churchill was first and foremost an oil man, despite the war time heroics he had his eye on the pie, carving up the oil wealth of the Middle East between BP and the Americans. WW2 was just a chapter in mechanised warfare that started in 1914 and goes on to this day, the war never stopped, certainly not in 1945. Things were only getting started then. Laos is a case in point - a secret war when more ordnance was dropped on the country than everything dropped in WW2.
We try to rationalise the behaviour of psychopaths, as if they were thinking in any type of common sense way.
I don't believe the dambusters thing was a shoe-string operation, although not quite Manhattan Project in cost, it certainly was not cheap. It was also 'standard' Lancaster bombers - the de-facto 'heavy bomber' of the time, albeit 'a small plane made of things like wood' in comparison to whatever we have today.
Ideally setting fire to the buildings housing machine tools (need to warp them, not shove them around and scour their paint with splinters).
But I can think of no more exquisitely vulnerable target than a refinery, and we were infamously ineffective at taking them out, starting with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Tidal_Wave and overall see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_Campaign_of_World_War_II especially the final paragraph.
I also note that it doesn't take long to repair railroads, and repairing them quickly after enemy damage has been a focus of engineers starting with our Civil War.
Although I'm not sure why we're bothering to reply to this message, seeing as how the very first point is infamously wrong, postal code SW1A 1AA (https://www.google.com/search?q=SW1A+1AA) most assuredly did get bombed: http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2009/sep/13/queen-mother-biogr... while the King and Queen were there.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Lindemann,_1st_Visco...
A lot of WW2 happened before Americans joined the party. At the start and up until the Blitz, both sides wished to avoid civilian casualties (incredible idea). Even the Nazis wanted to just take out the RAF, docks and munitions factories. But then some bombs landing in Berlin gave Hitler the idea to start terrorising British cities, so London's docks became a target in expectation that a lot of ordnance would miss and terrorise Londoners. Whitehall was also targeted - a 'decapitation strike' in modern parlance.
Coventry was removed from the map in summer 1940, to a certain extent Churchill had been waiting for this to happen (Bletchley Park had thee intercepts) so that reprisals could begin. And so it began. Bomber command kind of gave up on 'precision' and it then became eugenics - kill off the working class people! Bomb their houses! Factories, docks, railways were no longer the targets, it really was working class housing to be terrorised.
I have not heard about Churchill's advisor - Lindemann - on any History Channel documentaries, but not everything is as it gets told. I am not seeking a contrary view, just, the more you study a subject doing one's own research the more it differs from our own rosy propaganda. I also think that what the germans did in Namibia before the war is also quite fascinating, the depths of inhumanity that we learned of after the concentration camps were discovered were plain to see a generation earlier. It is as if the germans missed out on colonies and sought to make colonies in eastern Europe to make up for missing out on the land grab that the British (Portuguese, French and Spanish) empires had managed.
As for the Buckingham Palace incident, that was a stray bomb, not one of many aimed at the palace that happened to get through.
R.V. Jones in Most Secret War lays out an entirely plausible account of how Coventry happened. It's important to realize that militaries hide data like exact targets behind code names to avoid various sorts of exposure, and these code names are also used on what they consider to be secure channels. Famously the Japanese attack on Midway; as Wikipedia puts it (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Midway#Allied_code-b...):
Admiral Nimitz had one priceless advantage: U.S. cryptanalysts had partially broken the Japanese Navy's JN-25b code. Since the early spring of 1942, the US had been decoding messages stating that there would soon be an operation at objective "AF". It was not known where "AF" was, but Commander Joseph J. Rochefort and his team at Station HYPO were able to confirm that it was Midway; Captain Wilfred Holmes devised a ruse of telling the base at Midway (by secure undersea cable) to broadcast an uncoded radio message stating that Midway's water purification system had broken down. Within 24 hours, the code breakers picked up a Japanese message that "AF was short on water."
Ah, and in 1996 the decrypts were made available; per Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coventry_Blitz#Coventry_and_Ul...):
Since 1996 the Ultra decrypts for the relevant period have been available in the UK National Archives. Between 07:35 GMT on Sunday 10 November 1940 and 05:00 on Monday 11 November a German signal was deciphered and given the serial number CX/JQ/444, paragraph 4. This message set out code words to be used by aircraft on an operation named "Mondschein Sonate" but did not give Coventry as the target or a date. It did say that transmission of a figure 9 would denote "KORN" and hindsight has recognised this as the code name for Coventry. This was not realised at the time however, even though PAULA had been identified as Paris and LOGE as London. Indeed, the word KORN was used in two reports from an aircraft taking part in a raid on Southampton on 30 November, two weeks after the Coventry Blitz. Another decrypt on 11 November or early on 12 November gave navigational beam settings for Wolverhampton, Birmingham, and Coventry but no dates. There was a hiatus in Ultra decrypts from 01:15 GMT on 13 November until 02:40 on 15 November, by which time the raid was well underway: Churchill could not have received new Ultra intelligence on the afternoon or evening of the attack because there was none to give him. Intelligence from captured airmen and documents did not offer an unambiguous picture either.
Back to you:
As for the Buckingham Palace incident, that was a stray bomb, not one of many aimed at the palace that happened to get through.
Move those goalposts. You flatly said this had not happened. Per this account http://www.westendatwar.org.uk/page_id__39_path__0p2p.aspx, which I'm sure can be verified against more solid sources:
During the Blitz, Buckingham Palace and its grounds were struck on sixteen separate occasions (of which nine were direct hits). The Palace forecourt, inner quadrangle and South and North Wings were all marred by high explosive and delayed-action bombs.
According to it, the famous bombing I mentioned was deliberate targeting during daylight:
A single German raider specifically targeted the Palace with a stick of five high explosive bombs. Two of these hit the inner quadrangle, a third struck the Royal Chapel in the South Wing and the remaining two (one delayed-action) fell on the forecourt and on the roadway between the Palace gates and the Victoria Memorial. The explosions in the quadrangle ruptured a water main and blew out most of the windows on the southern and western sides. The interior of the Royal Chapel was lacerated. Four workers were injured; one later died....
The best proof of his lack of interest came at the end of the
war. Heisenberg and about ten other German nuclear scientists
were interned at Farm Hall, a country estate in England. All of
their conversations were secretly taped. When the news of the
Hiroshima atomic bomb was broadcast, these scientists could not
believe it. When they recognized that it was real, they asked
Heisenberg how it could have been done. His first attempt at
explanation was totally wrong! He hypothesized something like a
nuclear reactor, with the neutrons slowed by many collisions
with a moderator.
[1] http://www-personal.umich.edu/~sanders/214/other/news/Bethe....But the Germans never built any. They never built the huge industrial installations needed to separate uranium or make plutonium. The project never got beyond the lab stage. The Manhattan Project built several square miles of industrial plants. That was General Groves' contribution - he was a Corps of Engineers builder, had been in charge of building the Pentagon, and knew how to run a big project.
I like this quote from William Knudsen, which really sums things up: "We won because we smothered the enemy in an avalanche of production, the like of which he had never seen, nor dreamed possible."
[1] http://cen.acs.org/content/cen/articles/93/i39/Nuclear-Foren...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-2_rocket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Boy
Even if the Nazis had managed to nuke the D-Day beachheads - they were still going to lose to the Soviets.
Pre-Trinity, pre-Hiroshima most people had no idea what a nuclear weapon could do. You can tell a general twenty kilotons of TNT, but he isn't going to believe it until he sees it. See also: the Davy Crockett tactial nuke.
>There's a million ways that could go wrong,
Another thing that everyone knows, now. Remember, we used to do atmospheric testing of the things mere tens of miles from populated areas. https://imgur.com/gallery/8j0VRkn
My point was that the way the US delivered nuclear weapons to Japan and the delivery mechanisms upon which Cold War and contemporary nuclear arsenals are optimized, is not the sole way in which nuclear weapons can be used for effect.
Continuing our conversation, the fact that using nuclear weapons carries a risk of retaliation has defined geopolitics for seventy years and is what has given us the term Mutually Assured Destruction.
I am not certain that the US and UK would have been tremendously invested in retribution in 1945 had the Nazi's had used atomics against the Soviets in the East. This feeling is based on the shape of post war real-politik toward many former Nazi's despite the atrocities that were actually committed.
Finally, the implication that Allied fire bombing was somehow less ruthless than chemical weapons does not resonate with me. My take is that white phosphorous is simply easier to turn into a reliable stockpilable weapon than poison gas [particularly given changes in air pressure and temperature that bombs in a bomber undergoe]. It is my opinion that the Allies actual use of atomics speaks to the no holds barred nature of their bombing campaign.