This isn't hypothesis. http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2015/05/new-study-shows...
In particular, I would ask you to consider the following conflicts:
* The American Colonies vs. The British Empire
* The Bolsheviks vs. The Russian Empire and Republic
* The Mujaheddin vs. the USSR
Can you elaborate on how, in those cases, militant political action harmed the overall cause?
Is that enough for you?
I suspect that if you asked a historian, you could find many examples of movements that were utterly discredited after a turn to violence. Such as anarchism in the US.
There were possibly more anarchists predating the first Red Scare using violent tactics than state socialists, but Eugene Debs still ended up in prison, and I think it's pretty impossible to claim he was somehow violent.
Further, a historian would tell you that a societies' definition of "violent" is highly contextual; for example, the Occupy movement was classified as "violent" and subsequently subject to significant (and actually, physically violent) repression because as other comments in this very thread have pointed out, they used nonviolent civil disobedience tactics similar to the 60's civil rights movement.
Further, since we can't experiment, we can't make statements about whether or not there were delays in civil rights because of any particular thing. It could very well be that violent tactics from "extreme" leaders like Malcolm X caused backlash, but it might also be that media presentation of these events in a certain way was more causal of backlash, or that these events were polarizing, resulting in some people identifying more with the civil rights struggle while others identified more strongly with white supremacy. So no, it is not enough for me. Why is it enough for you?
If the events in question are polarizing and produce the outcome observed, that would be consistent with both the data and the hypothesis.
What more would you like to see? What would be enough for you? Can there be enough for you, or do you think this question is forever unknowable and to be relegated to the realm of radical hypothesizing forever?
Found in the article.
Militancy has drawbacks. Those drawbacks can in fact be measurable counterproductive. That's the hypothesis at hand.