Is the "required to seek active consent" actualy a bad outcome? From a customer point of view it seems better than "I assumend you wanted me to do x" regardless of what x is
The big issue is the fact that we have become accustomed to being relived of both the choice and the information about which choices thats been made for us. Which of course makes us a bit lazy since it's hard to make informed choices which probably is going to make a system like the one you described a hassle to implement but id say it's worth it to bring back at least a small resemblance of choice and control of your own information.