My experience has been that most people are very empathetic to "their people" and much less empathetic to everyone else, so I suspect you'd end up with the same people you'd get if you took the "hire more people like us" default.
My experience has been that most people are very empathetic to "their people" and much less empathetic to everyone else, so I suspect you'd end up with the same people you'd get if you took the "hire more people like us" default.
I think the point of that advice is to remind that for an astounding amount of people empathy is not at all a priority! It may be even seen as a weakness, in an unspoken way. Humanity and empathy should be a core value on a company's banner precisely because it's fairly explicitly discouraged by default in personal and work culture at large.
I certainly agree with that; I personally put effort into appearing less empathetic and less respectful than I normally am when I'm trying to get a job, just because I am more likely to get the job when I do that; my theory is that it matches most people's heuristics for "confidence"
(I mean, there is a cost... I'd prefer to work at a place that didn't value "confidence" - but not as strongly as I prefer to work.)
But yeah. I'm pretty sure people who are interviewing have no real interest in empathy or diversity. Hell, listen to just about anyone talk about "cultural fit" - everyone has an idea of what their new employee should look like, and there's not a lot of diversity (either in the 'inclusive of protected classes' sense or the "diversity of thought" sense) in that idea.
"Culture Fit" is a really problematic state of mind. I totally agree that it locks in on a 'type' and reduces diversity. It's a dangerous, ego-maniacal, and lazy way to hire.
It sounds like you make the same mistake as everyone else, thinking there is some connection between confidence and technical skill.
Appearing confident is completely unrelated to programming ability. confidence is a skill one needs to learn separately.