If I were to solve it, I would just give people democratic rights (pretty much everyone the same vote) to decide how economic resources are allocated. But lots (if not most) of people are against that idea.
If I were to solve it, I would just give people democratic rights (pretty much everyone the same vote) to decide how economic resources are allocated. But lots (if not most) of people are against that idea.
- People optimize locally, working for what they think is their best interest, even if on aggregate they lose. This is basic coordination problem; the very reason we form societies is because global optimization, often requiring to fogoe individual short-term gain, leads to better outcomes.
- The way people vote strongly depends on education they get; especially in our technological civilization, a lot of important issues (like energy) are beyond the understanding of majority of electorate. Democracy depends on educated populace.
- People are not independent actors wrt. to voting; in the age of free media, your votes will not reflect the "will of the many", but the will of most charismatic people on TV. Note that "the most charismatic" usually does not mean "the smartest".
And the `elite' optimizes locally as well, directly at the expense of the weakest.
To be clear - I'm not that big on authoritarianism. I just don't see the value proposition of democracy being actually realized. Given the points I mentioned previously, we are still ruled by elite, except that it is constrained to choose their options only based on popularity, and unable to make hard decisions in areas that matter[0]. About the only thing democracy delivers as promised is bloodless government transition. Even the actual work in democractic country's administration is done by unelected officials.
At this point I've given up hoping that democratic governments will help solve climate change or energy problems. Private companies may be able to, but that's only because they're capable of behaving in inherently undemocratic ways, like releasing a new technology upon the world (nobody asked us to vote whether we want to have Facebook or not) or projecting the will of single individuals onto the society ("you will drive electric cars, whether you want it or not", said Musk, and proceed to burn as much money as it took to make electric cars compete with ICE ones[1]).
[0] - even if such decision wouldn't immediately piss of half of the electorate by itself, your political opponents will make sure it will render you practically unelectable
[1] - yes, there were electric cars before, but it took Tesla to basically force the market into accepting them as an option, and they did that on purpose
The last objection I don't understand. The best way to know person preferences is just to ask them. If someone charismatic changes their preferences, so what? People change their preference based on other people all the time. As long as it is clearly their preference, we have to assume that it's in their interest.
The point of democracy is that people express their interest. There may be smarter people doing smarter decisions, but why should they make the decisions in the interest of someone else?
In any case, I think it's a good idea, often neglected, to structure society so that impact of any wrong decision at any level is minimized. Things like democratic decision-making, subsidiarity principle, reversibility of laws, non-discrimination, limited liability, social security, no capital punishment, time limited government contracts and free access to information all help.
As for the last objection - the typical voter's preference will be reflecting the political battles described above.
> People change their preference based on other people all the time. As long as it is clearly their preference, we have to assume that it's in their interest.
The problem is, it's not people changing their mind because they've heard someone reasonable saying something that makes sense. Politicians lie. Lie blatantly and lie on purpose. They hire the entire advertising machine, built out of professional liers and bullshiters, to convince people that their side of the debate is right by whatever means necessary. The average voter has to oppose people who are trained specialists in lying. I don't see how you could argue it's actually their preference.
But back to the primary reason. I could accept that start of affairs as fair, as long as we're dealing with things that don't matter much. But at this moment in time, we have several important problems - like supergerms, climate change and depletion of fossil fuels - that are going to destroy humanity in few decades, or at least pull us back into the medieval age. This shit matters. We need to make some hard choices and do some decisive actions soon if we want to have any kind of civilization surviving to the end of this century. And the democratic process is by design incapable of making those hard choices.
TL;DR: I don't want to "give power to the smarter" or a king or anything. I just want someone to actually do something about global warming and power issues before this stupid textbook-level coordination problem kills us all.
> The average voter has to oppose people who are trained specialists in lying. I don't see how you could argue it's actually their preference.
People have to oppose these people in all areas of life. By having democracy, you actually distribute power more equally and using money to gain influence becomes more costly (its much cheaper to buy a senator than to influence people to vote certain way, and the latter poses much higher risk).
I don't think people are that stupid. I agree they can be temporarily confused by lack of information or fear, and that in representative democracy, there is a risk of the person lying. But that's a problem with that system, and there are many options how to prevent that. For example, in Switzerland, on some referendums, people can get a summary information with arguments for and against. And often the debate itself is very healthy.
It seems to me this argument is blaming the victim. In all other areas of life, we call out the liar. Whether or not you can tell it's a preference depends on the information you have. Say a girl decides to sleep with a ladies' man, and he breaks up with her afterwards. If she knew, maybe she wouldn't do it. But at the time, she expressed her preference.
> But at this moment in time, we have several important problems - like supergerms, climate change and depletion of fossil fuels
As far as I know (at least in U.S. and my country), based on various opinion polls and so on, general public is pretty positive towards solving these problems. It's the actual politicians who are reluctant to act.
True. I'm basing on I need to learn more about those other systems, I might revise some of my opinions, which are currently based on my experiences with the democracies I know - Poland where I live from direct experience, and few big Western countries from news and reading stuff.
> By having democracy, (...) using money to gain influence becomes more costly
That's a win only if the cost is too high to pay; as it seems to me now, the cost is higher but not limiting, so the result is that more of society's resources are redirected towards that. See: presidential campaigns, and how much money, energy, time and manpower is wasted on what amounts to a zero-sum game.
> I don't think people are that stupid. I agree they can be temporarily confused by lack of information or fear
Yeah, I don't want to imply people are idiots - but it seems to me that the state of lack of information (and sometimes fear) is a constant in our societies. From what I read about the history of democracy, its basic assumption is that of a population well-educated in the issues to be decided.
> and that in representative democracy, there is a risk of the person lying. But that's a problem with that system, and there are many options how to prevent that. For example, in Switzerland, on some referendums, people can get a summary information with arguments for and against. And often the debate itself is very healthy.
I wish to know more. I'd love if someone with direct experience of Swiss process could tell how good is it.
> In all other areas of life, we call out the liar.
That's actually my core problem with continued existence of advertising/marketing industry (I include political campaigning under the term 'marketing' here). In other areas of life we don't tolerate such nonsense. If your friend tried to pull on you the stuff that is standard practice in marketing, you'd punch him in the face. And yet we accept this from companies and politicians, and we even turned it into a respectable occupation choice.
> As far as I know (at least in U.S. and my country), based on various opinion polls and so on, general public is pretty positive towards solving these problems. It's the actual politicians who are reluctant to act.
The issue I see here, and why I blame the democratic process for that, is that people may be "pretty positive towards solving these problems" as long as it doesn't require any sacrifices from them. Start talking about CO₂ emissions tax and suddenly you'll be violently opposed by people. Point out we need a new nuclear power plant, and the NIMBYsts wake up. This feeds back into the democratic process and so (that's why I think) politicians stay away from solutions. At this point we really need someone to force some solutions on people, whether they like it or not, and I don't see how (representative) democracy can help with that.
I really recommend looking at Switzerland; U.S. on state level also has lot of direct democracy and similar tradition.
> the cost is higher but not limiting, so the result is that more of society's resources are redirected towards that
It's not a failure of democracy, it's absence of it. Some people have more power due to economic inequality.
> basic assumption is that of a population well-educated in the issues to be decided
This is not really an issue. Switzerland and places in U.S. (not to mention Iceland) have more than 100 year tradition in direct democracy, do you think back then the population was better educated? And the sky didn't fall, in fact these places are some of the most advanced in the world.
> And yet we accept this from companies and politicians, and we even turned it into a respectable occupation choice
I agree.
> people may be "pretty positive towards solving these problems" as long as it doesn't require any sacrifices from them
In practice, not always true. There have been some examples in direct democracies where people voted for e.g. higher taxes. As long as it is fair, people can actually accept it quite well. But it requires lot of trust in the society, which Eastern Europe countries, for instance, may not have. Good democracy actually produces this trust.
> At this point we really need someone to force some solutions on people
The problem is once you start forcing solutions onto people, you have opened a really bad can of worms. Lot of dictators had good intentions in the beginning, but somehow their "forcing of solutions" got a little out of hands.