I've left the back of my credit-card unsigned for 2+ years, and in that entire time, and north of 500+ transactions with a signature, I've been asked for identification less than 10 times.
I wonder if there has been a single person challenged on a signature in the last 5+ years with a credit card if they even made the slightest attempt to sign in a fashion similar to what's on the back of the card?
But outside of those? Almost never.
This is, by the way, the reason software development is hard - if you were to approach this problem the way typical software requirements are defined, you'd only piss the clerks off. In real life, people dynamically adjust their compliance with procedures to run the common case with minimum effort and improvise if something unexpected happens.
> In the US, some customers write “See ID” or “Ask for ID” in the signature panel, thinking that this is a deterrent against fraud or forgery; that is, if their signature is not on the card, a fraudster will not be able to forge it. In reality, criminals often don’t take the time to practice signatures. They use cards as quickly as possible after a theft and prior to the accounts being blocked. They are actually counting on you not to look at the back of the card and compare signatures; they may even have access to counterfeit identification with a signature in their own handwriting. In this situation, follow recommended steps listed above under Unsigned Cards.
It makes even more sense given this guideline, from the same handbook:
> When should you ask a cardholder for an official government ID? [M]erchants cannot make an ID a condition of acceptance. Therefore, merchants cannot as part of their regular card acceptance procedures refuse to complete a purchase transaction because a cardholder refuses to provide ID.
(Source, PDF: https://usa.visa.com/dam/VCOM/download/merchants/VBS-06-APR-...)
Regardless - any time I'm making a large purchase (even with a signed card), you can be certain they scrutinize my government ID - I've never seen a retailer who has ever paid attention to the rules that stipulate you cannot make an ID a condition of acceptance.
It's purely a branding rationale. For some people, being "grilled like a potential criminal" by a checker would be enough for them to stop using the card or not shop at that store. Either way, it's a negative association between that merchant and that card for that kind of customer. Card networks have fantastic anti-fraud algorithms that are way more reliable than a bored teen checker.
Whenever a checker takes care to examine my credit card I make a point of thanking them for their diligence, as long as its within reason they're doing everyone a favor but the criminals.
This "yes-card" attack relied on having physically stolen the original card (not skimmed) and only worked against offline transactions using SDA, which, as far as I know, aren't supposed to happen in the US.
As long as merchants continue to accept magstripes the security benefit isn't really there, but, in the ideal world where they accept only chip-and-sig, it's still much more secure than MSR even without the added protection of a PIN.
Whole point of PIN was to move responsibility over to VISA and banks. This is why they kept claiming every transaction with chip&pin card is 100% valid and there is no chance of fraud.
Reading this article gave me LOL. Their super fraud prevention is asking the card for multiple pin verification before client enters real PIN, so if the card validates random bad PINs reader can flag fraud. This will stop scammers for ... one week? until they start programming shims to only validate one particular PIN making the card act like the real one.
1: http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/09/08/345820789/why-d...
Your signature just means you accept the terms of the cardholder's agreement.