When Gas Becomes Cheaper, Americans Buy More Expensive Gas
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Most people don't understand cars very well, but just about everyone understands that they are complicated and they need maintenance. So there's always an anxiety that the car is going to break. I think the way we deal with limited agency in an uncertain environment is to just "do what we can". So when there's an unexpected windfall at the pump (cheap gas), the maintenance-anxiety heuristic says "apply it to maintenance" and people buy premium gas. Because that's good for the car, right? And now they've "done something", so the anxiety is reduced.
Of course, it doesn't actually have any mechanical benefits, but this isn't a mechanical issue.
Higher octane is for high compression engines. It's a waste of money to use in in most cars.
If you really don't want to pay for higher octane fuel, buy a car that runs on lower octane fuel...
Don't use a lower octane than what your manufacturer recommends, that compensation is there as a safety precaution, not as a means to allow you to shift the standard octane your engine really needs.
Note that running your engine on fuel with lower octane number than what your manufacturer recommends is also a way to void your warranty (and since the damage is quite specific and the evidence is right in your tank there is a very good chance that will kick in).
If you habitually floor it, though, then yes.
An engine that knocks regularly will die, no matter what the power levels at which it takes place simply because it isn't designed to deal with that stress on a regular basis, engines are designed with some leeway but not so much margin that they could take such abuse and still manage the same life-span they'd achieve with normal use.
My thinking was this: peak cylinder pressure basically is proportional to torque, so at lower power levels cylinder pressure is overall lower. Even if the engine knocks, which will cause a spike in cylinder pressure, it starts from a much lower baseline, and there's also much less air/fuel mixture in there. Thus peak cylinder pressure for a knocking engine at low torque may not be much larger than that of a non-knocking engine at full power. But this is just speculation on my part, I don't have quantitative data.
It's also possible that it is the sharp pressure spikes that do the damage rather than the overall pressure level, in which case what I'm saying would be less applicable.
Just consider many countries sell gasoline with vastly different octane ratios. You buy a Honda Accord in the US or Australia or Canada and the choice of fuel is quite different there is no standard for premium.
There is a post of reddit where someone in Germany said regular is 95 octane and premium is 100 octane versus the US with regular 89 and premium 95. So there's a big discrepancy there how can the same cars in two different countries operate with such vast differences in octane?
Generally yes: but it's not a requirement. For example, Mazda's Skyactiv engines run at 13:1 (unusually high compression) and consume regular gas.
Use the octane your car was designed for!
So you end up putting fuel into your engine that contains higher volumes of water that is released into the engine internals. This causes rust and gums up carburetors. This is especially hard on small engines; lawn mowers, weed trimmers, and motorcycles. It's not good for your cars either and this has zero relation to octane.
In older filling stations with a single tank, they solve this by selling "premium" to everybody, whether or not you select 87 or 92.
Gasoline is usually a loss-leader for filling stations to bring people into the store, so I suppose it's a negligible impact on margins.
Source: I'm a former gas station owner.
Regionally, virtually all petrol (gasoline) for all fuel companies comes from the same refinery, with the same treatment.
I do buy premium for my small engines (lawn mower, etc) because (at least in my area) it's less likely to have ethanol added which is bad for most small engines.
Who are these people?
A lot of people, as it turns out, are not particularly bright.
(Now, ethanol is less energy dense than gasoline; right now the gap is 2 cents between E10 and E5, so you might make the calculation if you actually get more energy per buck from E5. It's another story for fuel consumption, though.)
So, no, maybe consumers are making the smart choice.
Also, E15 and higher fuel blends have been in widespread use in the US for 10+ years now. I don't think car engines die quicker in the US.
Here are some fairly extensive test cycles applied to real-world engines, which found that the effect closely mirrors the theoretical reduction in energy density (3-4% for E10, ~7% for E20).
Higher octane ratings are not generally beneficial for fuel efficiency unless the engine has been designed for them (compression ratio, cam profile, timing, tune). Dropping higher-octane fuel into an engine designed for a lower-octane fuel will generally not affect economy.
Bollocks. The energy content is slightly lower, but there is zero harm to automobile engines. Your unsourced "gearhead" friends share a common misconception and prejudice against ethanol. There is absolutely no issue with E10 fuel in cars with model years as far back as the '90s, or even earlier. Very old classic cars may have issues with some fuel line components, but even there E10 will not wreck the engine. As a fuel E10 is extensively tested on gasoline autos. Two-stroke engines are another matter.
And 2001 and newer autos can run E15.
running the incorrect octane is at a minimum bad for your mileage and can also be damaging to your engine...