My personal view of why it fails (as a housemate not an insider to the business) was the following: 1. Too much money too early meant they spent more than they should on things which weren't necessarily valued. Examples being hot-tubs in all the early houses, the vacation houses (I get they were an experiment) etc. 2. Poor financial management. Property at it's core is a simple business and getting the accounting/billing right is vital. I suspect that the leadership team didn't have enough financial knowledge of the books to run such a business, needed a grey hair CFO much earlier. 3. Premature scaling. I assume pressure from investors and the economics models showed you had to get mega scale to get VC rewards, and this lead to pressure to grow too fast. I moved from one house to another and it was clear there was a difference in how carefully the inhabitants were selected and this weakened the value proposition (the second house had two separate groups with very different and competing goals from living together).
I really hope someone gets this right, and not just for 20 something year olds. When I get married and have kids I'd love to have 5-10 other families sharing common areas, responsibilities etc. Figuring out how to build that community element and make it scalable is the hard part.