Due to a copyright claim, you are no longer monetizing the following
YouTube video. It is still playable on YouTube, but the copyright
owner could choose to show ads on it.
The key phrase is "but the copyright owner could choose to show ads on it".Google is automatically transferring the benefits of copyright to anyone who files a claim?
That seems ripe for abuse.
Theoretically, you could claim copyright of a video, show your ads on it, and profit until the dispute is settled (if it ever is). A popular video could have hundreds of thousands of views before a dispute is settled and a company the size of Sony could probably claim some form of copyright infringement on thousands of videos.
And there's no downside (other than the effort/costs of filing the complaints), a small content provider won't pursue the perjury clause in the DMCA, it'd be too hard to prove (if they know about it at all). They'll just be happy it's over and go on with their lives.
</tinfoilhat>