The Doxing Trend
schneier.com
schneier.com
Schneier is arguing for government regulation, and letting people sue for damages after an information breach, and I think he's right. We have enough data at this point to show that very few companies are going to take good care in this area unless a regulator or their insurance company forces them to. It's too hard, it's too expensive, and it's too easy to brush off the consequences when the inevitable breach happens.
Even more that people are terrible at keeping their own information safe. A collection of one-off facts over the past 8 years of a person's internet life can paint a rather vivid picture. You can tell how many relationships they have been in, if they have a new job, what country they live in, what town they might live in, what their pet's name is, who their friends are, and more.
With enough metadata it becomes trivial to find their social profile (where they often speak about bits of information contained in the metadata) and then you have their full name, family, friends, etc. At that point it becomes trivial to find more information on them.
Informing people is rarely enough to get people to understand. On the contrary - they'll blast all the info you need to know on their Facebook or Twitter. They'll take pictures of local parts of town and post them on Instagram, etc.
It's extremely hard to be doxed unless the user shares information with the public. It's extremely rare to be publicy doxed due to leaked credit card information or a company being hacked and a database being released.
The point of the article is that in a case like this, Apple and Amazon are both at fault, and should be held legally responsible.
[0] http://www.wired.com/2012/08/apple-amazon-mat-honan-hacking/
Thanks for the explanation. I do agree companies should be held responsible when they are too lax on identifying people as who they claim to be.
OTOH, I can see customer complaints about slow service and constantly having to prove identity w/ 4 last of SSN and such. It's an area where idealism and reality don't meet very well.
We need an avenue of recourse that doesn't rely on showing actual damages if we want to address the current market failure.