your statements don't conflict, it's just an interpretation of the term "very big." Lots of people are buying the softtops, but those people might not be the people still investing in high-end hardtops (if that's the term). If sales of one item are increasing without a concurrent, statistically significant and apparently causal decrease in the sales of supposedly competing items, then it's not really disrupting a current market. It's just making it a lot bigger and getting most of the new volume. You could say that the market is almost tangential to the existing surf shop market.