I don't think the Economist's ranking can be used for choosing which school to attend. It tells you how good a job schools do at boosting the earnings of the people who attend there---conditioned on who attends. In other words, they tell you how much the school does for a typical member of its student body. But if you're not representative of that student body (and you certainly won't be representative at many of the schools, especially the outliers!), this will not tell you how much the school would do for you.