We just have to realize that society is the issuer of currency and can just spend when necessary.
One of the big debates of the 21th century should be the nature of fiat money. Money is now a social construct (2). Money is infrastructure and it's all that society need to advance common goals (3).
(1) except maybe monopolistic public utilities
(2)http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2013/03/what-is-modern-moneta...).
(3)http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2015/01/bill-mitchell-demysti...
Property rights fundamentalists, like all fundamentalists, have the emotional benefit of experiencing low cognitive dissonance. But if inequality keeps increasing, they're going to be very surprised when they discover that when push comes to shove, most people value other things over property rights.
-Chamfort, yeah, the French guy that shot himself in the head twice and still didn't finish the job
Perhaps a better solution might be to fundamentally rethink the role of money, work, economy etc in a radically different world (robots, unsustainable population etc).
Also this;
> made mostly through their labor and innovation
is demonstrably untrue in many cases.
I'm just not naive enough to think that the ever widening income inequality and wealth consolidation/hoarding is not a bad thing.
And the grain of rice wasn't meant literally.
anyway, it's pretty damn obvious you didn't grow up in one of those marvelous "socialist/communist" societies that look wonderfully on the paper, yet fail miserably and consistently in real life. I've been there, and still getting to position of understanding naivety of some otherwise clever people in this topic (popular in western europe among young who grew up in a different systems, not sure about rest of the world). All these regimes do is bring out the worst in people in it, get into very ineffective modes of rule and centralized management, gradual (or sudden) loss of various freedoms, etc.
Hard work, innovation should be rewarded, not corrupt allegiance to current ruling elite. This mode brings the best out of people in matter of contribution to mankind. What we can improve is the ruleset/boundaries in law, punishing usage of loopholes, off shore taxation and similar. But people on that list didn't get there by avoiding taxes.
it would be nice if some Star Trek utopia would work, but we as humans and mankind are just not there yet, for various reasons. Maybe you are, but according to what you wrote, in contrary.
Now go throw a rock on some McDonald franchise, that will surely make you feel like contributing to well-being of all of us a bit. or even better - move to Russia, it's a fine example of a country sliding back to where it came from, or even better, true communist paradise - North Korea (let me guess, you don't have something important for that, do you)
I'm not a communist, nor have I ever believed communism as a system works.
Feel free to continue spouting your gung-ho rhetoric though.
("Their" labour is really an assumption we should challenge: Jim and Christy Walton didn't stack every shelf themselves, there's 2 million other Wal-Mart employees. Perhaps the future is they're all stacked by robots and you have two billionaires plus two million starving people; we might want to find ways of avoiding that future)
Waltons might not stack shelves, but they invented vendor managed inventory, which transformed the global supply chain and lead to many, MANY other things coming to reality. They also manage a multi billion dollar company. Perhaps one of those shelf-stacking employees can substitute them for a day. I'm sure it's not a big deal.
I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I've started a number of businesses, after all. But let's not worship people whose talent happens to be particular sorts of commerce.
I do know several people worth several hudrends of millions tho. They are CEOs of their own companies or companies they helped grow. I don't think anyone works harder than them in their companies. If there is someone, it probably is someone from the upper management.
>What they're good at is business, which is organizing and capturing the value of other people's labor and innovation.
You say that like it's easy-peasy. Everyone can do it, right?
I also know people in that bracket. None of them work significantly harder than some of the house cleaners and construction workers I've met. And even if they did, it's not like they work 10 million times harder. There are only so many hours in the week.
> You say that like it's easy-peasy. Everyone can do it, right?
It's not easier than anything else. But it's not appreciably harder. Read Warren Buffet on this. He's one of the best in the world, and he describes his success as coming from talent and luck. E.g.: "I happen to have a talent for allocating capital. But my ability to use that talent is completely dependent on the society I was born into. If I’d been born into a tribe of hunters, this talent of mine would be pretty worthless."
I note also that he was born into a family with business experience. His grandfather ran a store; his father, a stock brokerage. That sort of early education is of enormous help. (I know myself; my dad started programming computers in the late '60s.)
Managing a firm with 1200 employees for sure is 10 million times harder than moving boxes around.
But be my guest. Go to North Korea or Cuba. I'm sure people are very happy there. Everybody is equal. Just some are more equal than others.
You seem to have shifted your metric from working hard to the work being complicated. But again, plenty of people do complicated work without getting zillions of dollars for it. I know math PhDs who do amazing technical work; it's far more complex than the workaday accounting done by executives. I know organizational consultants and senior HR people who are way better at designing organizations than your average executive. I know plenty of front-line managers who have much more complex managerial problems than senior execs.
What you're missing is that as with Cuba and North Korea, the people on top get disproportionate rewards solely because they are on top of a large power structure. They all "deserve" those rewards for the same reason: they won at the musical-chairs game of hierarchy. Were Fidel Castro and Mao Zedong smarter or harder working than their competitors? Maybe. Or maybe they were just lucky in either the talent lottery or in how things played out.
The only difference here is that our game is built around competing entities that, on average, create economic value, so there's possibly more social utility that results from the hierarchy games. But the people creating the economic value are mostly the ones doing the actual work.
I generally don't begrudge people the money they collected. The game is the game. But let's not confuse winning the game with "deserving" the winnings in some moral sense. That's the just world fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just-world_hypothesis
Sort of, yes. But my issue with this is not that the obscenely wealthy have so much more per se - I guess there is a moral argument to make there, but I'm not the one to make since it doesn't bother me too much either. I'm mostly with you on that: speaking in strictly material terms we shouldn't mind too much if a small group of people are much much better off than everyone else, provided that everyone is still looked after and the situation is improving.
And, if you're some trickle-down theorist or whatever, you might even say that some people have to be obscenely rich for there to be any progress. I don't agree with that at all, but it's another argument you hear.
Anyway, outsized wealth inequality like this need not be just a problem in a material sense though. It's also a problem in a political sense. Wealth and power are pretty highly correlated, but democracy functions best when power is more diffuse. So a concentration of wealth interferes with healthy politics and governance, and that's why I don't like the massive disparity in wealth we see know, and why I think it's very dangerous.