Feds Never Charged the Real Hacker in the Matthew Keys Case
wired.com
wired.com
If the FBI simply failed to supply any evidence to support a prosecution, one has to ask why they victimised Keys, while letting the actual perpetrator off scot-free. No pun intended.
1: There waws absolutely no reason why McKinnon couldn't have been prosecuted in the UK but when his solicitor claimed that no crime had been committed in the UK because the computers McKinnon had hacked were outside the UK (which is incorrect - the Computer Misuse Act applies to hacks where either the perpetrator or the target is in the UK), they made the monumentally stupid decision to try to extradite him, with the end result that he was never prosecuted or punished for his criminal activity.
It's also interesting to follow how the cost to fix this "hack" (i.e. change the headline back and delete the credentials that should have already been deleted) kept going up over the course of the trial. Initially under $5,000, then $5,000 so that the FBI can get involved, then eventually $929,977.00 [0].
[0]http://motherboard.vice.com/read/why-the-government-went-aft...
If I'm cat sitting for my friend, and she makes a copy of her house keys for me, and when I'm done catsitting, I give those keys to some random guy on the street in a hooded sweatshirt... who is liable if he uses the keys to enter her house? I'm pretty sure she would blame me.
yes
> A hacker going by the name “Sharpie” then used the credentials to access a Tribune server and make a minor alteration to the headline of a Los Angeles Times news story.
That, along with "sending harassing emails" and "locking a co-worker out of their workstation", is why this guy [not the hacker] is getting 25 years.
Meanwhile, the people who caused the largest financial crash in recent history have not gone to jail.
No, he is not getting 25 years. He is being sentenced for a crime whose statutory maximum punishment is 25 years, for an offense which, under the circumstances put forward by the prosecutors, has a base guideline sentence of about 5 years (which is also what prosecutors have said they will seek in sentencing.)
The defense is likely to, in sentencing, challenge the prosecution position on damages, which may result in the guideline range being substantially lower. There is, basically, zero chance of a sentence anywhere close to 25 years here.
Read Popehat on this very case: https://popehat.com/2015/10/08/bad-reporting-on-matthew-keys...
If convicted on these charges, SWARTZ faces up to 35 years in prison, to be followed by three years of supervised release, restitution, forfeiture and a fine of up to $1 million.
https://web.archive.org/web/20120526080523/http://www.justic...
Yes they offered him 6 months finally but that is not how it starts. Plus in this country you get caught red handed you get a nice plea bargain and get less time than someone who might be innocent and they went to trial because they don't feel guilty and boom higher sentence for not taking the plea bargain.
90% of cases never go to trial. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/criminal-justice/the...
My friend who swore he was innocent and went to trial on a he said she said had zero evidence was offered 18 months went to trial and got 12 years. That was more than some murders, man slaughter and rape. If you have a FBI trial your defense will cost millions or you take the plea bargain. Justice system is broken.
Are you saying the DOJ is lying or that the fact that Aaron Swartz was told he could be facing 35 years in jail?
This is so odd. I feel like people are down voting me to defend the DOJ's handling of Aaron Swartz?
There is no substance whatsoever to the "35 years" figure.
The reality is that we don't really have to ask what Swartz was thinking, because after his death, his lawyer wrote up his predicament. The trial would have been ruinously expensive, but there was a very good chance that even if he was found guilty, he would serve no custodial sentence.
You can back that up by finding the federal sentencing guidelines, lookup up the CFAA guidelines, and applying them to Swartz, who had no previous criminal record, caused no significant damage in his offense, and sought no profit from his crimes (all factors considered by the guidelines).
It's very hard to shoot down an urban myth as virulent as "Swartz faced 35 years in prison", though. Especially when so many people want it to be true.
> It's very hard to shoot down an urban myth as virulent as "Swartz faced 35 years in prison"
Because that is in fact what the DOJ sent out to the press in this document stating the non-mythical number 35.
Trying to understand why 35 years is a myth the public continues to hold on to: Pragmatically you are saying that could not happen but the empirical evidence of DOJ communication to the public is 35 years.
I'm certainly not defending the DOJ. A very thorough and compelling study of mass incarceration published earlier this year suggests that prosecutorial overzealousness probably accounts for more of our prison population than any other factor.
But the "35 year sentence" claim has nothing to do with Swartz's predicament. He had excellent legal representation, both formally (he had a series of well-qualified criminal defense attorneys) and informally (he had a support system compromised of several of the most respected legal scholars in the country). Every one of them would have told him that he could, and should, ignore the "35 year" figure from the DOJ's press release --- the DOJ writes a similar press release for every headline prosecution, and in each case applies the same absurd heuristic of adding up the maximum possible sentence for all counts, ignoring the sentencing guidelines and offense grouping rules.
The 35-year sentence is also mooted by Heymann's own initial negotiation with Swartz, where he threatened Swartz with a 7-year sentence. 7 years was his ambit claim; it was the worst possible case Heymann could generate, and a fabulously unrealistic one given the CFAA sentencing guidelines.
It's a deception that serves DOJ interest in making their activities seem more significant and newsworthy, and the press don't bother to challenge it, either through laziness out because the artificially enhanced dramas serves the interests of the press.