Working with an old code base
felix-cat.com
felix-cat.com
Derek Sivers rewrote 90,000 lines of code in 12,000 lines... after 2 years on a failed rewrite. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=58429 Maybe the lesson is that before you can renew your code, you yourself must be renewed?
Or: You cannot solve a problem at the same level you created it.
Though my father had a rotten little shed that needed attention. He tore down and rebuilt sections. Besides a split level roof lines, it really seems like a complete redesign. I think the key is that few things were up for discussion. Also, having a sturdy base to work from made things easier. (and it stayed in operation the whole time.)
With code, I see similar ideas. You probably shouldn't tear down and rewrite more than half at a time...and you should probably decide whether the world still needs the original product.
Sure, it's going to take you longer to get stuff done in the short term. But in the long run, you'll appreciate it.