GlassDoor makes it easy for that reputation to spread.
Job security between the two is an illusion. It doesn't matter if you're contract or full-time. You can lose one just as easily as you can lose the other.
I think an employer might be more willing to take a risk on a candidate they're not sure of if it's only for a few weeks. "Well, we're 50/50 on this guy, so let's bring him in for 2 weeks and see how it goes." On the other hand, if it's a permanent hire right off the bat, they'll want to be a fair bit better than just 50/50.
If I/we make a job offer to someone, it's because we think you're a good fit and you will be productive. Bringing someone in for 2 weeks, then someone else in for a month, then another guy for 2 months wastes even more time than just interviewing them each for half a day. Not to mention the uncertainty and morale effects on the rest of the team.
I think it's better if there's a new hire that isn't working out, to just give them some severance pay and fire them quickly. Obviously you should be hiring with good intentions and believe that they will do well after due diligence, so 50/50 isn't a good probability to hire someone, it just causes a lot of disruption and lot of bad will.
A trial period essentially tells candidates "your first three months on this job are a kind of extended interview". People are rejected after interviews based on standards of evidence far, far lower than the ones commonly used to terminate employees.
Software firms can be ruthless about at-will employment, but they can't do that while retaining staff and recruiting new staff effectively. Companies that are ruthless about at-will employment are ostracized, which is why that kind of ruthlessness is rare in the industry.
I wish I had a better way to ask this, but... can you actually provide any evidence this is true? It is directly counter to my ~10 years of experience, and I've seen it at many companies that are home-run-level successful (i.e. there's no way one could qualify them as having trouble recruiting). I'm not sure I could name even one company that is "ostracized" for their hiring practices.
The only way that I can reconcile this theory with my experience is if I take the maximally extreme definition of "ruthless" ... something like firing someone in their first week after enticing them to leave a job and move across country. That, of course, will get you a bad reputation quickly. But I personally have not seen measurable negative consequences for firing alleged low performers for little to no reason within a 2-3 month period.
I would be curious (and pleased) to hear if this is just an unusual sample of experiences I've had.
Edit: let me clarify that when I say "I haven't seen measurable negative consequences" I don't mean that I have done that to anybody. But it has happened to upwards of 10 people I know.
Do unscrupulous companies fire for culture fit? I'm sure there are lots that do; I wish I knew more about which ones they were.