Sure, I'll give it a shot, although I'm not amongst your downvoters.
There are two ways to build a system like this: one requires no training and uses a heuristic. That is, you come up with a formula that you think will rank candidates well, plug input variables into it, and sort candidates based on the score. Such a system cannot learn, it is fixed; it can only be improved by a human tweaking it. The fact that we have no way to measure our success is irrelevant.
The other way is to build a learning system, and a learning system needs to be trained. This means there must be either a set of training data (of positive examples with specified outcomes) or an objective goal function that can be computed on the output over which an optimization can be run.
Without these things (i.e., when the results are too subjective and we're unable to assign a reliable score to the outcome), machine learning is impossible, and the algorithm can never be trained to perform better than a human.