Compared to the alternatives of Skype, WhatsApp, SMS, Hangouts, iMessage, etc it's a good chat service, with a relatively lightweight native client on multiple platforms, actual working sync, and good recovery when used on poor Internet connection.
Compared to the alternatives of Skype, WhatsApp, SMS, Hangouts, iMessage, etc it's a good chat service, with a relatively lightweight native client on multiple platforms, actual working sync, and good recovery when used on poor Internet connection.
It is unethical to market snake oil.
The hate stems from two main sources:
1. They're claiming to be secure in a very flamboyant (even arrogant) manner by challenging the world's cryptographers to break their protocol, but the contest is structured to be unwinnable regardless of how shitty their crypto actually is.
2. Telegram spends less time improving their crypto (which is full of WTFs) and instead markets themselves to people who aren't technical enough to figure out how shitty it really is.
Seriously, avoid Telegram. If you want Signal to work on more platforms, send a check to Open Whisper Systems and help them build up their team to cover more area.
The 4 or 5 people in the nsa that actually do any work don't stand a chance against several hundred million baby breeders with ak47s.
Are they super-duper safe? No. Will driving our cars grant you immortality? also, No.
But no car can promise this, and driving any car inherently runs the risk of dying - No car is provably 100% safe! If you're really worried about this, just don't drive!
Most car drivers won't care anyway, very few people crash their cars on a day-to-day basis, so it's not really relevant.
</good-natured-sarcasm> exaggerated/straw-man comparisons, or appeal-to-low-standards doesn't really satisfy these kind of concerns... <good-natured-sarcasm>
If it's not actually secure then they shouldn't advertise it as secure.
An app that advertises itself as secure but isn't is naturally going to attract more hate than an app which doesn't advertise security in the first place.
Nobody forced them to advertise security. If they just wanted to be a a good chat service with the advantages you listed, they could just do that. But if you advertise security, you had better deliver!