Why has Buffer lost 50% traffic? Consumers aren't as stupid as you think
medium.com
medium.com
>"We had trouble even reaching 3k people out of those 200K subscribers."
My list isn't anywhere near 200K, but I've gone for trying to optimize the list for high open/click rates as opposed to just trying to get the subscriber count high.
Double opt-in is helpful in that you have to really want the newsletter and mean to sign up for it. It has also been a good exercise to remove people from the list who haven't engaged with it in the last 3-6 months.
Because the newsletter is just a list of links to content from the previous week, if subscribers aren't clicking through, then there is really no point in sending them the newsletter. Plus, I pay for sending the newsletter out, so wasting money sending it out to people who don't engage with it isn't something I want to do.
Great service in theory, but in the way it's being used now, it tips the signal:noise ratio of content in the wrong direction.
It boils down to that old rule of thumb that 80% of results come from 20% of actions.
When you get companies who think productivity in marketing is similar to other silos like engineering and measured in results pushed, (or when you get 'social media rockstars' who think the same) they create a ton of noise and no one is interested in what they have to say. You develop a style of almost ad-blindness to their posts.
It's far better to say a few things and nail everyone of them, than to say everything and botch most of it. It can be a challenging lesson and one that I think a lot of us have been guilty of in the past.